| What if someone’s spirit, floating around in heaven, longed for a more brutal existence? Longed for hate, pain, and death? The thought of spirits returning to inhabit human shells has been captured before, but never in such a compelling, entertaining, and beautiful way. Another Heaven has obvious problems but they are forgotten very quickly by the viewer. Unanswered questions and plot holes loose significance in the haunting atmosphere of the film. It’s often labeled as a horror film, and while it does have a many elements of that genre, it is at it’s heart a somewhat noir-ish thriller/drama.
To give to much of the plot away is to ruin the film. Because of this, I suggest not reading the summery on the back of the Hong Kong DVD because it will spoil parts of the film for you. Detective Manabu (Eguchi Yousuke) a team of police investigate the gruesome murder of a man. The soon discover that his brain is missing – and its location is more than a little disturbing. Veteran detective Tobitaka (Harada Yoshio) works with Manabu to uncover the crime. Asako (Ichikawa Miwako), a rather unattractive, though seductive, former relation of Tobitaka tracks him down. Learning of the murders and methods, she reasons that the killer must be a woman, because no man could complete the equation. Internally, Tobitaka agrees, knowing of the small handprints on the victim, though externally his “manly pride” leads him to exclaim that men are just as capable. As the investigation proceeds, we learn that Asako and Tobitaka’s internal instincts were right – and the woman, Kashiwagi Chiduru (Okamoto Yukiko), seduces three men. One of the three makes moves on her as she prepares a salad. She is chillingly unnreactive until she suddenly slams the knife into the cutting board, turns around, and proceeds to have sex with him before breaking his neck. Another of the two, returning from getting groceries, saves himself by giving her a brutal head injury and running away. The third, who earlier had been drinking with his nose bleeding (a cultural reference to horniness), cowers in a corner. When Tobitaka arrives, Chiduru is lying dead on the floor, and he peels part of her head away to find that her brain is apparently missing. Upon an autopsy, they discover that her brain was not removed – it shriveled up into a corner and the “killer”, a kind of entity that neither of the detectives can understand nor accept. As the film progresses, it moves through various twists and turns and constantly keeps the viewer guessing until its final minutes.
George Iida, director and author of the screenplay of Rasen, the unofficial sequel to Ring, creates a chilling environment for Another Heaven. From it’s brutal and unflinching opening to it’s blazing finale, his style enchants the viewer and brings them into the film in a way few films do. He holds nothing back when showing the brutal remains of the victims, and yet it’s never excessively disgusting. Though his relatively quick cuts imply that he’s not very sure of any of his shots, hi composition, movement, and camera placement is great in almost every instance. I’m surprised and disappointed to find that this is one of the few films to which he leant his directorial talents.
The acting elevates the film above all the other films of its genre. The weakest of the cast, Ichikawa Miwako, is only week for the first 30 or 40 minutes; as her character starts to take of, so does the quality of her performance. Eguchi Yousuke does very well conveying the wide range of emotions his character faces and in showing the confusion and at times inner disgust that Tobitaka faces. Okamoto Yukiko is great in her hauntingly seductive role, and all of the actors playing vehicles of the supernatural killer play their roles very well and leave the viewer thoroughly disconcerted.
As I mentioned earlier, Another Heaven has its share of problems. The motivation for the removal of victims’ brains is never explained. Manabu and Asako’s relationship changes almost unbelievably quickly. However, the film’s strong points more than make up for these shortcomings. Some have commented that the film is sexist and degrading to women, and that is not true at all. I instead see this film as showing the strength of women. It may not be as satisfying to the more extreme feminists as Audition, but those who claim that it is derogatory obviously didn’t pay close enough attention to the film. If you’re a fan of films, and don’t mind a somewhat hefty amount of cadaver gore, Another Heaven is a film not likely to disappoint you. |