Executioners: Viewer Comments

Viewer Comments Viewer Comments:
Executioners
All Content Used With Permission.


TIP: Log In to enable enhanced Interact features.NEED HELP?

    by AA19519


An excellent piece of work by Johnnie To and Ching Siu-Tung. A far better movie than the original HEROIC TRIO. Yes, there are fewer fights and less action scenes than the first movie, but overall EXECUTIONERS is more of a complete movie with a better plot, better screenplay, better acting, and quality fights. It was more emotional and dramatic, further solidifying the excellence of Johnnie To. Definitely a recommended movie, but please watch the digitally remastered version (HKL D'agostini)
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by City On Fire
    www.cityonfire.com




I didn't like Heroic Trio. Executioners is the sequel to Heroic Trio. I didn't like Executioners either. I could end this review right there, but you'd probably like some more details.

Actually, this is a little better than its predecessor, I think, but that's not saying much. It's full of silly-ass moments that severely undermine the bleak, harsh atmosphere that it tries (perhaps too hard) to sustain. There's Mr. Kim (Anthony Wong, in a totally different role than in the first movie), a disfigured guy who dresses like it's still the 1700s and controls the world's (or at least Hong Kong's) only known source of clean, drinkable water. All other water has been contaminated by radiation from a big blast a while back which has reduced many people to living in the streets, even though plenty of buildings remain standing. (This blast has also, apparently, done away with color television, as the movie keeps showing us crappy old black and white TV in a feeble attempt to cement a post-apocalyptic setting. And, speaking of limited color palettes, this is one of those Hong Kong movies where every other scene is black and blue...just like all the bruises that people DON'T get from the fight scenes where they dance around without actually hitting each other. They're not all like that, but enough of them are to piss me off.) The government keeps sending people to look for a fresh water source, and they keep getting killed. In one early scene, the widow of one of these unlucky souls barges into the office of the police commissioner (Wonder Woman's husband), undeterred by dozens of armed guards, opens fire with her assault rifle, and then unleashes about 20 rounds directly into her own face. The final result of this is that she dies with a little splash of blood on her forehead. The government is also concerned about Chong Hon (Takeshi Kaneshiro), a charismatic "spiritual leader" (he wears white robes, but never talks about anything spiritual) in Mr. Kim's employ.

So, what have the three titular ladies been doing these past few years? Well, Wonder Woman (Anita Mui) is quietly playing homemaker with a young daughter who spends half the film shrieking "Mommy! Mommy!", Thief Catcher (Maggie Cheung) is still nabbing outlaws for cash while whistling about the never-ending fall of London Bridge, and Ching (Michelle Yeoh, formerly Invisible Girl, but now you can see her) is delivering medical supplies ("I have to get these supplies to those in need safe and sound," she says to herself, as she calmly drives her truck through a big stack of barrels packed with explosives instead of going around them). Ching has a masked, hunchbacked ally named Kau who communicates through crude body language and grunts, and gleefully helps her beat up bad guys. He's really the only likable character in the film. So, of course, he dies. But at least he's not alone. Executioners has one of the highest body counts (percentage wise) I've ever seen in a Hong Kong film. By the end of the movie, almost everyone is dead, yet I still felt unfulfilled.

Directors Ching Siu-Tung and Johnnie To use the film's dystopian setting and high production value to cover up all sorts of nonsense. People keep dying on their mission to locate "the fresh water source" because the surrounding terrain is heavily booby-trapped. Apparently, the radiation that tainted the rest of the water also wiped out all knowledge of how to build things like aircraft and mine detectors. Nevertheless, Thief Catcher and a guy named Tak (Lau Ching Wan) locate this holy grail after just one night of walking, and they're not even going at full speed because they've got Wonder Woman's brat with them. Wonder Woman makes herself a new mask with a piece of scrap metal, pounding out the eye holes with a bolt taken out of a prison floor, and when she puts it on, lo and behold, it's a perfect fit, just as pretty and streamlined as her old one. When the President informs the populace that it is once again safe to drink "normal" water (no real explanation is given), people joyfully turn on their taps and begin to slake their collective thirst; never mind that the pipes and the water passing through them would have an enormous rust content after such an extended period of disuse. And...(skip the rest of this paragraph to avoid an even bigger spoiler than the ones I've already thrown at you)...when Mr. Kim rips one of Ching's arms off and holds her over his head, she yanks an exploding crossbow bolt out of her body and blows them both to Kingdom Come (thus making the Heroic Trio a Heroic Duo)...or so one would think. She dies a messy death, but he just loses an arm. I sense a pattern here. Admittedly, this does lead to the coolest moment in the film, when an enraged Thief Catcher repeatedly punches Kim's burnt, bleeding stump. Still, it's silly as hell when he dies by hand grenade a few moments later. If that killed him, why didn't the first explosion do it? And don't say "super powers".

Bah.

If you can look past its multitudinous absurdities, you may find some amusement in Executioners. The plot is a bit more complex than that of Heroic Trio, and the overall presentation is a bit more solid. But it's still not something I'd recommend to anyone with a distaste for cheese.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Ernie Chen


Well, if you seen the first one you gotta watch this one, too. But it lacks the spirit of the first one. The phantom of the opera character is rather comical. Be prepared to see Kau appearing again (he was not roasted as one might assume). The bathtub scene is incredible.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by SS

In an apocalyptic HK of the near future (after the PRC takes over maybe?), rich masked villain Mr. Kim has a stranglehold on the supply of uncontaminated water, and it's up the Heroic Trio (Michelle Yeoh, Maggie Cheung, and Anita Mui) to forestall a military coup. An exceptionally ridiculous plot (even by HK standards) is offset by a few great fighting sequences and, of course, the eye-appeal of the female leads.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by LEH

The sequel mixes in elements of Total Recall and Blade Runner with some surprising plot twists. More serious than the first movie, it is still extremely entertaining. The scenario concerns an evil mega-corporation that's got a stranglehold on the worlds water- supply. For various reasons (which shouldn't be revealed for those who haven't seen it) another sequel seems unlikely. But who knows...
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!