Yi San: Viewer Comments

Viewer Comments Viewer Comments:
Yi San
All Content Used With Permission.


TIP: Log In to enable enhanced Interact features.NEED HELP?

    by Min




Volume 2 of this series is somewhat disappointing; while Lee Seo-Jin is still good, he is also limited to looking worried or thoughtful, and flashing a beautiful smile occassionally. At this point, I wonder if it's the script or the director, who also directed "Dae Jang-geum" (A Jewel in the Palace), since so far the story is more about Song-Yeon (Han Ji-min) than the future king, Jeongjo.

I'm less than impressed with her performance, as it is unimaginative, and limited to pouting (as are all the actresses portraying the damos in the art dept in this story), looking confused, stuttering, and saying "huh?" or "what?". After a while, it's really irritating. Again, it could also just be the script and/or the director, especially since many actors and actresses from "Dae Jang-geum" have shown up in "Yi San".

The addition of odd background sound effects seems mismatched to this series; the costume, props and sets often outshine the performers. The scant handful of truly good performers are outnumbered by the campy, stereotyped ones. Strangely, there are scenes in volume 2 involving secondary characters that don't add to the story, and they seem to be more "contractual obligation" scenes than anything else.

I hope volumes 3 and 4 get better.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Min




I found "Yi San" a very entertaining series, at least after watching this first set of disks. I bought it primarily because Lee Seo-jin was so good in "Damo"; he is just as good in "Yi San" (though it does appear that he may be a little too mature to portray a 20 year old). Most of the characterizations are excellent, with great comic relief, though a few appear almost cartoonish, which detracts from the believability of the story. Knowing that lengthy series are sometimes edited for DVD distribution, I wonder if the DVD version edited out parts which may have added to character credibility.

The beginning of the story is well written and well-performed by the child actors, whom I found refreshingly non-obnoxious and very talented. The shocking death of Crown Prince Sado at the hands of his father, the king, is a strong contrast to the innocence of the young leading characters. It also makes me wonder exactly what kind of person the king was. Later, the story becomes a bit confusing with so many people involved in conspiracy, but remains interesting. The painfully restricted Confucian attitude that dominated Korea at that time shows in the horrified response to Song-Yeon (a "mere art damo") being able to draw and paint on her own. Yi-San, known for his original ideas and fairer rulership, sees nothing wrong with his friend's talent, making him even less popular with the palace crew and creating more ammunition for the conspirators.

I'm eager to see the next installment of the series.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!