 |  |  |  |  Great semi-realistic karate choreography. Decent plot. Finale was a little underwhelming; choreography got a little sloppy. If you like Sonny Chiba karate films, you'll probably like this. | | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | Y | I really enjoyed the final fight. It just felt real and gritty and desperate. A masterful blend of physicality and emotionality. 5-stars for me. | Choco |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  Beautiful, powerful, and simple. No wonder it won the 2007 Montreal Film Festival. This is real karate...or as close as you could get without heading to the dojo yourself. | | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | Y | | Choco |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  No wire "flying" or other special effects, just a solid plot and excellent performances by the main characters. Would recommend to any martial arts film fan. The fight scenes are credible and exciting. | | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | Y | Top quality for sure. | Choco |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  Excellent movie!!! As is typical with Japanese karate and kenjutsu films, it has a more dynamic storyline (e.g. all old school "Zatoichi" films, "Yojimbo", "Sanjuro", "Sword of Doom"). It captivates with all business moves. It gives an interesting perspective on how Imperial Japan and corrupt officials were usurpers in an early 20th century context, and how someone can become consumed with their esoteric knowledge of the arts and go down the wrong and consequently ruinous path. The fight in the quest for the black belt by the "poison" Shishidan or Shihan and would-be Jakideshi (direct disciple of the grandmaster) could have been a little more demonstrative of their skills as a final sequence, but I still "got it". | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  One of the best martial arts films of all time. If I had a chose a top five in the martial arts genre, this film would be in it. Many times with martial arts films we sometimes let things like bad acting and bad story get a pass as long as the martial arts on display is great. Tony Jaa films are good examples of this. "Black Belt" is top notch in every aspect. I'd wager that even viewers that aren't into martial arts films would also love this movie. | | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | Y | Totally agree. Glad you loved it so much! | Choco |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  If you want to see a movie with good karate, look no further. The story is good and the action is excellent. | | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | Y | It manages to be sensational without being...sensational about it! :) | Choco |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  This is not an action/adventure. It is not a war film, though the Japanese invasion of China is integral to the plot. This is a great film; a grown-up drama with realistic martial arts. It belongs in your collection. If you do not have a collection, here is your first disc. | | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  | 
| WOW!! From the moment I saw the trailer for "Black Belt" (or "Kuro-Obi", which I like saying by the way), I knew I was in for something special! The first 15 minutes alone stopped me in my tracks and compelled me to sit back and enjoy this work of art!
"Kuro-Obi" works on all fronts: story, script, cinematography, cast and especially the martial arts. Leads Akihito Yagi (Int'l. Meibukai Goju Ryu Karate Instructor) and Tatsuya Naka (Japan Karate Association General HQ (Corp) Instructor) surprisingly give acting and film fighting performances rarely found in one thespian. Once I saw their martial techniques, I knew I was looking at truly skilled martial artists.
Regarding the action, you won't find the highly dance-like Peking opera style of choreography like Hong Kong films, or the MTV style quick editing most US films use (to hide under trained stuntmen), but what you will find is very realistic fight scenes that are very entertaining!
"Kuro-Obi" is a great film that presents a story of honor, loyalty and how we must cope in a world of good and evil. Definitely a must-have for any fan of martial arts and/or film, period! Buy it, share it! |
| | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | Y | I knew these performers could do the moves, but they're very affecting actors, too. | Jeffrey Frawley | | Y | | Sgt. T | | Y | on the money my friend!!!! | SHAWBABY43 | | Y | You called it, right down the line! | Prayingmantis888 | | Y | Completeley agree, man. I've already shown this film to a few friends and now they're telling more folks about this great movie. | Bastard Ronin | | Y | We're in enthusiastic agreement. :) | Choco |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  Totally different, realistic. Most people won't get this, but "Black Belt" is a lesson learned, about choices we make and the growth we develop through our experiences, and standing on our morals and principles. | | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  My absolute favorite Karate movie. It truly does show why karate masters of old are better than the black belt factories of today. Inspirational in every way. | | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  Despite the inclusion of authentic karate, the fighting was improbable, typical for martial arts themes, and the actors were flat, but some of the visual elements were good. The mystical message didn't make much sense--even though karate is supposed to be defensive, the best defense is a good offense. I don't think switching to B/W for the last fight and finishing in color again was very effective. | | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | N | I agree with Choco-This film didn't need to be your typical flashy martial art film-if you've seen a lot of bad martial arts films like a lot of have when something like this comes around you really appreciate it-especially if you,ve studied martial arts | Little Dragon Fan | | N | Sorry you didn't like it more, I thought it was really spectacular in its understatedness. | Choco |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  "Black Belt" was easily one of the most pleasant surprises I've had in a long time. I was totally unfamiliar with the movie and bought it on the strength of various reviews and comments, most of which mentioned the fantastic training and fight sequences. Well, I'm not going to rock the boat on this one, either. I was absolutely entranced by this film from the very beginning. It's not a terribly complex or original plot, yet it somehow does an amazing job of holding your attention throughout. I've been both a fan and a practitioner of the martial arts for going on two decades now and I can't recommend this film highly enough. | | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | Y | Very good review | Little Dragon Fan | | Y | I felt exactly the same (except for the part about you being a martial artist--I can't feel the same about that part myself because I'm not a martial artist myself). :) | Choco |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  I heard the hype, I watched the film, and it was awesome! It is always nice to see real experts doing the fighting in a movie. It is even better to see how martial arts can be treated by people who respect them and understand what they are truly about. The morality and symbolism in the movie is as subtle as a brick to the head, but that only emphasizes the message. I am reccomending this to anyone who like martial arts, of any style. | | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | Y | Totally Agree! | Little Dragon Fan | | Y | True words. This film will easily move to both cult and legendary status. | Bastard Ronin | | Y | Great review for an awsome film! | Sgt. T | | Y | Glad you loved it too! | Choco |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  I am biased in liking this movie because I used to be in Goju ryu and before Mr. Yagi was born. But regardless of what style karate you are in, this movie is a fine tribute to the practitioners of the period. | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  | 
| Whether it be Karate, Kung Fu, Tae Kwon Do or Jiu-Jitsu; ALL forms of martial arts are a way of self expression. The fantastic Japanese martial arts melodrama, “BLACK BELT” (aka. "Kuro Obi", 2007) explores the character of Karate itself and is loosely based on a true story. The film effectively balances the YIN and the YANG using the tumultuous military period in a 1930s Japan as its backdrop. It delves into the face of violent confrontation and the reflection on moral responsibility.
At an isolated dojo headed by Sensei Eiken Shibahara (Shinya Ohwada), three students: Giryu (Akihito Yagi), Taikan (Tatsuya Naka) and Choie (Yuji Suzuki) train relentless under their master’s instructions. One day, when military officers threaten to ousts them from their own school, the encounter leaves Choie badly wounded with Taikan and Giryu taking up the challenge. Giryu defeats the commanding officer without throwing a single punch that led the officer to commit Seppuku.
After their master’s death, the trio was hired to train military soldiers since the two both displayed impressive prowess. But fate interferes when Giryu becomes wounded by the officer’s vengeful children and he becomes separated from the group. Taikan becomes influenced by the ways of the world while Giryu befriends a kindly family. Fate has played them in opposing hands and an inevitable showdown is poised to bring the traditional Giryu against the corrupted Taikan--just who is truly deserving of the KURO OBI?
“Black Belt” is a thinking man’s martial arts film. The screenplay by George Ilda is a lush impressive breeding ground for melodrama and with Shinichi Nagasaki’s (A Tender Place) direction taking a more somber, novelistic approach to its story; the film explores the tensions of Karate. The film is an expression of the spirit of Karate, and Director Nagasaki has opted for a more character-driven approach in place of dazzling and unrealistic martial arts displays, for which he is to be commended. I am in total awe when a director instead goes for the spirit of a concept rather than just show how cool fight sequences can look.
The cast, Tatsuya Naka and Akihito Yagi are Black Belt holders themselves and they look very natural. Now, don’t mistake my earlier comment that the film is lacking in the number of fight sequences; there are quite a great number of fight scenes that display the beauty of Karate. Although the film focuses more on its characters and while the film’s plot is a bit simple, the action and fights are nicely placed to keep us entertained. The fight sequences themselves are a form of character development. As I’ve said, martial arts is a form of self-expression and so the film capitalizes on this idea. The action is there to build the characters‘ credibility, and it feels necessary to get to the film’s resolution. Unlike most martial arts films that have the story revolving on the action scenes, in this film, the action revolves in its plot.
The fight sequences by Fuyuhiko Nishi are smooth and VERY realistic. Most martial arts fans always see the choreography of the fights as a film’s major selling point, and this film delivers; the fights are AWESOME to see and more impressive as it avoided the use of wires and extravagant stunt work. I have never witnessed such well-choreographed fights since I saw real live competition. The camera work stays at a distance so you can see the movement between the fighters. The fights are hard-hitting and looks quite real, they aren‘t overly long and excellently paced. These characters are supposed to be lethal weapons but no one said they were emotionless. The fighters in this film feel very human, you see their concentration in their eyes and they can feel pain. The magic is that they manage to overcome the pain.
From the film’s opening act, you see the depths of Giryu, Taikan and Choei’s soul. Taikan is a young man who revels in competition and violent encounter to find the art’s meaning. Choei is the weakest student, but he is level-headed and truthful to himself which is why he was chosen to pick their master’s successor after his death. Giryu is very traditional, Shibahara’s teachings are similar to a religion to him and he would rather die than to stray from his teachings. “Karate is not to throw a punch or a kick, never attack, instead defend against an opponent’s attack--parry and stave off the opponent. This way you can reach perfection” as quoted by Sensei Shibahara.
While the film is quite predictable, the direction is very solid and the script is sharp. I called this film a Martial Arts melodrama because it focuses on its characters but let me once again make it clear that action fans won’t be disappointed. The absence of CGI and wirework in its fights are the film’s biggest strength and simplicity is its expression. The final encounter is shot in black and white perhaps to emphasize the clash between the Yin and the Yang, or to remind us that Karate is an ancient art that existed for hundreds of years.
“KURO OBI” is a beautiful film, it is definitely a thinking man’s film. The film set out to express the soul of Karate and director Nagasaki has achieved what he wanted to do by carefully measuring his approach. The film’s simple plot may be its Achilles’ heel but as with Karate, simplicity is often the most effective approach. After all, throwing too many punches can hurt a fighter himself, as can pitching too many ideas can hurt a film. “Black Belt” is solid, and nicely executed.
What is really worth fighting for? The goal is not for competition but the battle for enlightenment. Black can never look dirty, and a fighter must be pure. The Belt represents willpower.
“From Strength will come compassion, from compassion, strength will emerge”
Highly Recommended!! |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  | 
| Damn, I'm all disco dancin' on this one. I got hip way late. They all told me what was up and it still caught me unaware that I was about to watch an all-time great.
See, things have changed a lot since I came up, especially in movies. Between extreme amounts of CGI, wires, "star power", and blatant commercialism, films these days (especially martial arts films) have basically lost sight of the essentials. "Black Belt" brings back that absolute sense of what is essential. It replays that classic theme of colleages/brothers/students that go their opposing ways to discover their own personal paths. This theme was popular in a bunch of old school kung fu flicks and some cop/triad flicks from the 90's. The most recent case of this plot device that comes to memory is "Tai Chi Master". This device is used perfectly for this film and produces a necessary contrast to appreciate the finer philosophical aspects that occur both subtly and obviously throughout the movie. A true zen film. It's so zen it hurts. It's all about that ol' "my path is my path because it is the path set before me" crazy phunk.
The fights were amazing. It was the most pure karate that I have seen in any movie or show ever. The precision and expert proficiency of every fighter is showcased beautifully and brutally. It was the best and most authentic karate movie that I have seen. Period. When we conjure up thoughts of karate movies we probably think of Sonny Chiba or Jim Kelly. Perhaps even the "Karate Kid" movies and, let's face it, all those ninja movies that we watched in the 80's were basically karate flicks. I'm not sure Japan really got a chance to make a truly authentic and original karate movie since the 80's due to the whole Hong Kong style action craze that hit around '99. After that Japanese action and martial arts movies transformed into a complete mixed bowl of martial arts, boxing, gymanstics and various dance movements--basically a wanna-be Peking opera performer style. Technically this change over probably started in the late 70's.
Because of these trends in choreography and movies, we had not really been given a chance to see how good a true and pure karate movie could be. I needed a movie like this to come along and show me that great films are still being made and that using themes that may be somewhat old can be used in such refreshing ways that it revitalizes the genre.
"Black Belt" will probably be many things to many people. For some it is a powerful drama, for others it will be the best samurai film they have seen in a long time, and to many others it might be just another martial arts flick--but hopefully at least an exceptional one. For me it is to karate what "Ong-Bak" is to Muay Thai, what "Prodigal Son" is to Wing Chun" or what "Throw Down" is for Judo. It displayed its method in a way that we felt, understood and appreciated with masterful class and diligence. "Black Belt" is a good example of the whole reason why I watch movies in the first place. I want to be taken away to another world and shown fascinating things. I wasn't disappointed here. A great storyteller/philosopher once said that a journey has little do with where you are heading but more to do with what happens on the way. This film embodies that sentiment. A drink to good journeys!
Stuff you might think or say when you watch this movie:
- Damn, Taikan is a bad-ass.
- Damn, Giryu is a bad-ass.
- That was the sickest reverse punch that I have ever seen!
- Ooooo!
- That was some pretty deep shit.
Well, thanks for playing, folks. Tune in to next week's show when we will bring little Billy back from the grave using only tic tacs and a copy of the Necronomicon. |
| | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | Y | It is as good as you say. | Jeffrey Frawley | | Y | I must say the fans in my faves really know martial arts films. They get all the nuances in great storytelling that only true fans would understand! | Little Dragon Fan | | Y | Nuff said! Totally agree! | Sgt. T | | Y | Amen, brother! Damn I'm glad you felt this way about "Black Belt"! Not sure I could have handled your rejection of this classic! :) | Choco |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
|