 |  |  |  |  Not as great as the first segment, but if you're a huge movie fan you'll enjoy this as much as I did because of all the homages and references Quentin used to make this film--I thought it was excellent. The acting is above average, the cameos are plenty, and it's overall a great film, both this and the first. | | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | Y | | JV47842 |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  | 
| Don't tell me that I don't finish what I start. Speaking of which, I don't know where to start. Quentin pulled the old pretentious artist schtick by doing exactly what he wants to do rather than consider the essence of the story and core audience of the first volume. See, the first one was basically a samurai flick, this one is a spagetti western. This does not make for a natural or fluid transition. QT has managed, through this somewhat selfish and Hollywood-esque method, to capture the attention of many types of crowds and creating a movie whose two parts may have completely different fan followings. Kind of gimmicky corporate mess in my opinion but whatever. There is just insufficient action in this one. Everone talks about the big cat fight with Uma and Daryl and how it was this great fight. Too bad it's not. What fight were you folks watching?!? That fight is garbage. Just plain ridiculous. This expert female killer can't figure out a way to draw or use her sword in an enclosed space so it starts to play out like an SNL sketch. Quentin was gracious enough, however, to cast Gordon Liu as a stereotypical throwback of the generic, mean, but dilligent crusty turd of a master. All the fights suck! The best fight in this movie isn't even in this movie. It was removed. David Carradine vs. Michael Jai White. It is short but somehow very satisfying. The final showdown? Fucking disappointing. This was the ultra thick, cushy pillows of padded bras. We were kind of promised so much but we got so little. Ten fucking seconds and it ends with a corny "special secret technique"--the kind indigenous to all those goofy old schoolers that were great when you were young but now you have to watch them drunk to really get a kick out of it. The saving grace of this long winded station of smoke and mirrors is one actor's performance. An actor I hate. I still view David Carradine as a tool of a corrupt and racist system that got his entire career off the blood, sweat and hard work of an icon. In my personal opinion he is one of the men responsible for Bruce Lee's death. Bruce Lee developed the concept that the show Kung Fu was based upon. The idea was catered for Bruce to be the star. Unfortuately thanks to good old bigotry, Hollywood opted for a young Irish dancer to portray a Chinese kung fu master as opposed to an actual Chinese kung fu master portraying something that comes naturally with credibility. Back then David Carradine was probably like he is now. A shameless, greedy, unethical, corporate bitch of a prick that apparently liked the idea of pretending he was Chinese--as he went on to do so for over two decades. When Bruce didn't get this part he had to work much harder to achieve the promises he had made to himself years earlier. All that extra work and effort wound up take its toll on Bruce and he was dead by 32 and nobody knows why. It is entirely possible that if doors were opened to him earlier he would not have had to travel so much, campaign, work and train while dealing with the jet lag and malnutrition that comes with an extraordinarily busy lifestyle. Perhaps it could have turned out much better if in your struggles society itself is not against you. But perhaps I have tripped too hard and too far off topic. As I was saying, this movie features David Carradine's best performance around. It is honestly (and I hate to say this) quite captivating and perhaps even pitch perfect (the Superman speech was fantastic). However a fine performance and some well written dialog can't offset the fact that it unbalances the entire flow and meaning of the first volume. As volume 2 I give it 3 stars. On its own maybe 3.5 to 4 stars but it is not on its own. Thanks for reading and support your local dojos, gyms and Kwoon. Peace out. |
| | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | N | Almost anything Tarantino could throw at us which didn't have the battle in the House of Blue Leaves (ie Part I) would be a visceral letdown, but I like this a lot more than you do. | Jeffrey Frawley | | Y | both films are great | KungfuManiac | | N | Kill Bill as the whole is a good movie that mixes and matches different genres. I think you really missed the whole point of the Kill Bill movies. The fight in the trailer was not great but still entertaining. | Rhonda Bale | | N | | Ashley | | Y | Needless to say I hated this one too! | JAY LEE | | Y | No one hates this film more than me and I like most of QT's films but this was the most uncomprehensive film I've seen out since eraserhead | kangkane | | N | I hate how the films are split up. To review Kill Bill u have to see the whole pic as 1 big epic film mixing spagetti & fu genres. U can't dislike the other 4 not going all kung fu. The 2nd played as noir & spagetti with lil fu, but more detail backstory | JV47842 | | Y | I think I hated this film much more than you did. But I can't honestly tell if it's because of its endless, mastubatory speechifying or because it's so clearly inferior to part one. Either way, a big let down. | Choco |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
|