Gerd Ma Lui: Viewer Comments

Viewer Comments Viewer Comments:
Gerd Ma Lui
All Content Used With Permission.


TIP: Log In to enable enhanced Interact features.NEED HELP?

    by Curtis G




If you're looking for the recent "Born To Fight"--the one with the terrorists--let me warn you: this is not it. Evidently director Panna Rittikrai liked the title enough to reuse it, but only that and a couple of stunts connect this movie and his 2004 so-called remake. (There's not even an IMDb.com listing for this movie.)

On the surface, BTF appears to follow a very simple plot, but it gets so complicated that I still have no idea what was going on. There's some stuff about a lawyer and a notebook, and then some guys in matching jackets beat someone up. (It takes so long to get to the title sequence that a buddy I was watching it with thought it was over and said, "Is that it?")

We meet the main character, P'Tong, practicing martial arts with his son and daughter. The Matching Jackets Gang shows up to fight him and he beats them all. I have no idea what the point of that was, because then some guy P'Tong knows (his former boss, I guess) gets out of his car and tells P'Tong he needs to go to the city to find someone.

P'Tong makes it to the city, but everywhere he goes, some new gang tries to beat him up. He meets up with the inescapable comic relief; they find Uncle Jam and then fight some more. Guys in black coveralls and ski masks jump around in the dark and get P'Tong blamed for something or other. There's some nonsense about mistaken identity, but I was never clear on who the bad guys were or why they needed to kidnap Samsung or Sampan or whatever that guy's name was that P'Tong was looking for. At the end, suddenly the ski-mask ninjas show up again. Finally we get a fight scene worth waiting for (and a bunch of painful-looking stunts that Rittikrai recycled for Tony Jaa). But no terrorists.

The comic relief was mostly irritating, but there were a couple of genuinely funny moments. The girl was cute, but absolutely worthless. The one time when I thought she was actually going to fight, she stood up, clenched her fist...and then stepped back and started cheerleading for P'Tong. She deserved the beatdown she got a few minutes later.

I applaud the effort, but for the most part, the experience is like watching any no-budget early-80s cookie-cutter Chinese kung fu movie. In some regards, it's downright primitive: the acting is terrible; people and vehicles obviously start from dead stops at the beginning of takes; and the vehicle chases take place at about five miles per hour. But hey--this movie led to another, and another, and the rest is history.

Overall, "Born to Fight '84" may be worth a look if you really like old school martial arts movies, but for technical proficiency and sheer jaw-dropping stunt work, see the remake.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by RD11706
    www.hyphenmovies.com




"Born to Fight" (aka "Gerd Ma Lui") is Panna Rittikrai's first film, and while some people's first movie is greatly lacking, this one is almost the complete opposite. This film contains stuntwork so great that you see Panna recycling it in later films.

The film itself has many flaws. The direction and acting are probably mediocre at best. The storyline is relatively standard, and possibly relies too heavily on two characters looking similar.

All that aside, there are several great action sequences in this film. You can see the wheels beginning to spin for films like "Ong-Bak", "Born to Fight", and "Tom Yum Goong". The motorcycle chase scene is particularly good, but every fight is full of awesome stuntwork and good concepts. This film also features a little more kung fu style fighting than most of Panna Rittikrai's other films.

This film has some really excellent fighting and stuntwork that needs to be seen, but it’s extremely low budget and looks like an old Lo Wei or Huang Feng film. If it had the production quality of "Ong-Bak", everyone would need to own this movie.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Muhtar


No big deal with the plot, only the fight scenes gets 4 stars. Superb action, I would say that it's much better than "Ong-Bak" and "Tom Yum Goong", those movies maybe have the cinematic magic and lots of acrobatic fights, but this has the extraordinary choreography.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by MF19790


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by aardvarks


Should be purchased only by the Tony Jaa completist. While the movie has decent action scenes the age of the movie and the low-budget really is glaring. The remake film with Dan Chupong is an overall better film.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!