A Dirty Carnival: Viewer Comments

Viewer Comments Viewer Comments:
A Dirty Carnival
All Content Used With Permission.


TIP: Log In to enable enhanced Interact features.NEED HELP?

    by RD11706
    www.hyphenmovies.com


"A Dirty Carnival" is another Korean gangster film, heightened by some great character work and storytelling.

The acting is very good. All of the actors are spot on. Yoo Ha’s direction is very good. He has a good sense of both style and realism. The story is a well-done gangster movie with the added twist of a film director who’s making a film about gangsters. The romance and character development are also particularly well done. The action scenes are some of Jung Doo-Hung’s best stuff. It’s more of his usual gangster swinging, but it seems to be best done here than almost anywhere else. There’s a lot of action relatively early in the film and then it calms down for a while, but is still enjoyable. I was surprised at how good and agile the lead was.

"A Dirty Carnival" will catch you by surprise with its great characters and storytelling in an almost tired genre.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by JV47842




The 2006 Korean gangster picture "A Dirty Carnival" reminds me of Hollywood gangster pictures that James Cagney would star in. Mr. Cagney starred in a lot of crime pictures for Warner Brothers in the 1930's. His character was always some mad gangster lunatic for vengeance. James Cagney's role in "White Heat" reminds me of the starring role of this film.

The story is fascinating, about Byung-du who is a 29-year-old career criminal working for the middle-rank enforcer Sang-chul. Burdened with a terminally ill mother and taking care of younger siblings, Byung-du is feeling financial pressure as a substitute patriarch. When the big boss President Hwang is cornered by a corrupt prosecutor, Byung-du volunteers for a whack job and wins the big man's trust. However, his real trouble begins when friend Min-ho, an aspiring movie director, asks him to be a consultant for the latter's debut film.

The performances from the actors and actresses were wonderfully done. The cast made it look easy, and that is a trick, especially in a movie full of twists and turns.

I absolutely love the score of the picture. It has a classical instrumental French vibe to it, and somehow it fits perfectly in this Korean crime movie. The action--or should I say killings--was realistic and it shows. The punches, kicks, and stabbings were done realistically. There was no Hollywood element to it. The director and writer, Ha Yu, made an excellent gangster movie. “A Dirty Carnival” has beautiful shots. Though it is violent and gritty, Mr. Ha Yu has a great eye of the world. In this film we see two sides: the civilian side of living, and the gangster side of living. It’s an achievement how he captures them both.

“A Dirty Carnival” is the most realistic and violent gangster picture I have ever seen. The performances and story are captivating to watch. The score is amazing. I love this picture.

AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YThe pressure was on. I bought this flick because of your review. Kudos. I loved it. Great call.Garvinstomp
YA gritty gangster film that needs to be seen by more people.Black Belt Ninja
Y"Dirty Carnival" has an amazing musical score, it makes the film so alive. This being a gangster film it lets loose of what the audience expects from a gangster film. The film is a real joy & a gem for anybody, its sad tht not enough people have seen itAshley
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by A. Stana


Awesome gangster movie.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by TL44191


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by AC3950


A solid gangster film with depth of character and an emotional core. Life imitates art, but sometimes art is larger than life. See the film.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!