A Chinese Odyssey 2: Cinderella: Reviews

Reviews Reviews:
A Chinese Odyssey 2: Cinderella
All Content Used With Permission.


TIP: Log In to enable enhanced Interact features.NEED HELP?

    by HK Film
    www.hkfilm.net




Like Quentin Tarantino's latest Kill Bill, A Chinese Odyssey was originally shot as a three-hour movie, but was divided into two seperate films when the studio thought the market wasn't right for a longer work. So for all intents and purposes of this review, I will be treating the two films (subtitled Pandora's Box and Cinderella) as a single entity. Yes, I know I must be violating some rule of film criticism (something which, frankly, this site barely pays attention as it stands now), but A Chinese Odyssey is meant to viewed (and admittedly much easier to be reviewed) as one movie.

The films are an adapation of a popular novel named "Journey to the West". Steven Chow plays a theif named Joker whose relative peace is shattered when two mysterious women (Yammie Nam and Karen Mok) show up at his hideout. It turns out that Joker is the reincarnation of a creature known as the Monkey King. The King's mentor, Invincible Monk (Law Kar-Ying) is coming to find Joker so he can once again become the Monkey King, and a motley crew soon shows up to try and take the Invincible Monk, who can grant whoever eats his flesh immortality.

That plot synopsis really only covers the first part of the first movie. As you might expect for a film that runs for over three hours, A Chinese Odyssey has a very complicated plot, even moreso than your average wuxia movie. When you factor in Stephen Chow's "nonsense comedy", things get a bit weird to say the least. There were a few times where I was scratching my head, wondering what the hell was exactly going on, especially during bits like the part where Invincible Monk starts singing golden oldies. But Stephen Chow's charisma and humor keep things going, and Ching Siu-Tung's action sequences are exciting enough that the viewer can forgive some of the shortcomings presented by the story itself.

Overall, though, A Chinese Odyssey didn't fully click for me. Perhaps it was due to the low budget (there are only four or five sets used in both movies -- it just lacks that "epic" feel a film like this should have), sometimes haphazard and uneven story development (the movie sometimes tries too hard to interject "real" drama into the proceedings) or a plot that is a bit confusing in places, made worse by the badly-translated subtitled present on the DVDs. Despite these problems, A Chinese Odyssey is still a pretty fun film that's worth a look if you're into Stephen Chow's body of work.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by J. Swanson



If you didn't see the first Chinese Odyssey, this sequel will lose you as surely as the Bermuda Triangle. And even if you did, part two remains just a hair away from incomprehensibility. Evidently continuing the saga of the Monkey King (Stephen Chow), Cinderella at least doesn't take itself too seriously. In one scene, as the Monkey King is abandoning his spiritual teacher to a prison cell, the old master breaks into his own Cantonese rendition of a Motown tune in an attempt to win back his prize pupil. And a few minutes later, one of Monkey King's quasi-lovers shrinks herself to the size of a fingernail and jumps into his chest cavity to have a conversation with his heart, which looks like a hyper-inflated basketball. Those examples merely mark the beginning of a series of thoroughly absurd moments as the Monkey King goes on to skip through time and space to battle the Bull King, his Minotaur-like nemesis. Good luck.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!