G.I. Samurai: Viewer Comments

Viewer Comments Viewer Comments:
G.I. Samurai
All Content Used With Permission.


TIP: Log In to enable enhanced Interact features.NEED HELP?

    by davidoleary


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by EC1872




I generally have mixed feelings about "time travel" movies, because they inherently involve a logical paradox. If every action causes a consequence, which leads to more choices and subsequent consequences, that still implies a linear progression of time. If you went back in time and somehow got your ancestor killed, it cannot be possible to still have a timeline where than ancestor lived had offspring, etc., such that you were born and are living in the present day. However, if you affected the timeline in a "parallel alternative universe," well, then you never really went "back" in time at all.

Anyway, I love Sonny Chiba's films and decided to suspend disbelief and check out the film. As it turns out, I'm not disappointed. At its most basic, the plot invovles a detachment of Japanese Self-Defense Forces soldiers who somehow get trapped in a strange phenomenon that sends them back to the Age of Warring States, along with their weapons and equipment, namely a tank, a helicopter, and a patrol boat.

They are soon discovered by Kagetora (aka Uesugi Kenshin, historically a famous warlord) who eagerly embraces them as allies. The SDF soldiers, led by Lt. Iba (Sonny Chiba), later do join forces to fight with Kagetora, as Lt. Iba rationalizes that by "changing" history perhaps they might cause another distortion in the universe to force a higher power to return them to their own time.

Nonetheless, the film is less about science fiction, and more about how people might change if thrust into extraordinary circumstances. A few such as Cpl Yano decide to take advantage of superior firepower to loot, rape, and kill, forcing Iba hunt him and other renegades down.

Meanwhile various spies track Iba, his men, and their exotic hardware. As Iba develops a strong friendship with Kagetora, learning the old ways of horse archery, kenjutsu, and yari spear combat, it becomes apparent that he loves his new surroundings. In modern Japan, he is but a junior officer in peaceful times, but in the 16th century, he can become virtually a king, and he might not want to go back even if given the chance.

The highlight of the movies is definitely for me the re-interpreted battle of Kawanakajima. Historically, Kagetora faced off against another great general, Takeda Shingen in one of the most spectacular battles in feudal Japan. In the movie, it's Iba and his tiny squad against Shingen's thousands of samurai.

What's truly fascinating is how the Takeda army tries to adopt innovative tactics, weapons, battlefield intelligence, and advanced planning in an attempt to overcome Iba's technology.

It's a breathtaking battle worthy of any samurai epic. Flags flutter in the air, the various divisions are in full armor and colorful uniforms, masses of cavalry and ninja go in action, and there are ambushes galore. Ultimately, Iba barely manages to triumph against seemingly overwhelming odds, but not without losing his war machines, and even the most powerful tank must eventually run out of fuel and ammunition.

What follows is rather anti-climactic and sad, even if somewhat predictable, for in a ruthless winner-takes-all era, how long can Kagetora and Iba stay allies?

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by LW36458


Awesome movie--saw this when I was a kid. I rented it over ten times... "G.I. Samurai" (AKA "Timeslip", as it was called here in The Netherlands): this movie made a huge impression on me. This movie and "Zu: Warriors" are the two movies that got me into collecting Asian fantasy and sci-fi movies.

Then there was a remake that should never have been made.

Please people, watch the original. This movie is awesome--my favorite 70's Chiba movie.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by SP5181


This film rules. For everything wrong with it, there are ten things done just right. Plus it stars Sonny Chiba - your Guide to Quality.

The best part, and one that I have not seen reproduced in other time travel films, is that the Warring States people are not portrayed as idiots. From the start they take intelligent, effective action to try to neutralize the technological advantage of the time travelers. This is a fine film and I recommend it to action-lovers almost without reservation.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!