Riding Alone For Thousands Of Miles: Reviews

Reviews Reviews:
Riding Alone For Thousands Of Miles
All Content Used With Permission.


Rating, Out Of 5 Stars
It must have been slightly galling for long-time Zhang Yimou devotees to see their beloved director championed by some critics after the worldwide success of 'Hero' and 'House Of The Flying Daggers' while previously lauded films appeared to be swept under the carpet. Thankfully for them - and those of us who were looking forward to seeing a more intimate kind of work from the great Chinese artisan - he has returned to the pastoral with 'Riding Alone For Thousands Of Miles'.

This paean to rural China is told from the perspective of Gouichi Takata, a Japanese man desperate to be reconciled with his estranged, terminally-ill son. Despite his trip to Tokyo to be by his son's side, Gouichi is refused access and has to rely on his daughter-in-law for regular updates as to his condition. When Gouichi discovers that his son was working on a documentary about a Chinese Opera singer, but was unable to complete it due to his encroaching ill health, he elects to devote his time to completing the task. He travels to China to find the singer and finish the documentary, hoping the act will finally thaw relations between him and his son. The task is complicated when Gouichi discovers that the focus of the documentary is now serving a jail sentence and attempts to reach him are stifled by bureaucracy. As the prospective film-maker tries to get past the red tape he gets to know a variety of local characters, foremost among these is a lonely boy whose father is also serving time at the state's pleasure.

Zhang Yimou returns to the gently-paced, beautifully-shot stories that initially placed him onto the world stage, while also providing a keen insight into a land that was, until recently, shrouded in mystery and mythology. 'Riding Alone For Thousands Of Miles' takes viewers on a similar journey to much of Yimou's earlier works, the protagonist searching for answers and closure in the vast landscapes of China. Not that the familiarity with the concept is necessarily detrimental; Yimou is such an assured film-maker that his development of the material has all the hallmarks of quality one expects from an auteur. The story is developed with the languid confidence that Yimou displayed in works such as 'The Road Home' and 'Not One Less', utilising a pseudo-documentary intimacy to explore the subject matter.

Yet, despite the fact that this is a 'comfortable' viewing experience, it fails to be the return to past form that was expected. While there's much to savour and the execution of the material is hard to fault, it never manages to have the emotional core that made earlier works benefited from. Although we grow closer to Gouichi throughout the story - certainly closer than to the characters from 'Hero' and 'House Of The Flying Daggers' - the obvious turmoil he's suffering fails to resonate as it should. The peerless Ken Takakura cannot be faulted as he conveys more pain and contemplation in a few silent moments than the whole script can muster throughout. Rather it is the lack of development behind the central dynamic - why the father and son have become so bitterly divided is never explained nor even hinted at, leaving us with significant ground to make up throughout.

'Riding Alone For Thousands Of Miles' offers a pensive 100 minutes with the kind of devotion to China that shows clearly where the director's heart lies. There are subtle digs at the bureaucrats, though these satirical swipes are never as sharp as Yimou's founding years produced. Nonetheless, despite never catching the imagination in the way that it should - it simply lacks the balance between the dramatic and the ethereal - it is a film that offers intelligent, if flawed, viewing.

-Dragon's Den UK (see my profile)
http://www.dragonsdenuk.com

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!




ALTERNATE SYNOPSIS:
For the first time in years, aging fisherman Takata Gou-ichi boards a bullet train to Tokyo when he learns his estranged son is gravely ill. But at the hospital, his son refuses to see him. Daughter-in-law Rie urges Takata to watch a videotape of a documentary his son was filming in rural China. Moved by what he sees, Takata vows to complete his son's work. Though laden with obstacles, his odyssey into the heart of China and the kinship he develops with a fatherless boy and the villagers who care for him recaptures a sense of family he thought he had lost a long time ago.

-Sony

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!




Rating, Out Of 5 Stars
Chinese director Zhang Yimou, having followed two epic films in Hero and The House of Flying Daggers, returns to his roots with a low-key drama that ends up being even better than his more high profile endeavors. There is no kung fu to dazzle audiences, no dazzling color schemes, no breathtaking visions of idealized landscapes, and no lavish art and costumes to draw us into a sumptuous period piece. This is a simple story about simple people, but nevertheless, still as powerful in its themes and moving in its emotional core so as to make a more lasting impression on all that view it.

A middle-aged Japanese man named Takada (Takakura, Mr. Baseball) travels to rural China to try to do something for his estranged son who has just been diagnosed with terminal cancer. Shortly before the diagnosis, the young man, who spent much of his time making documentaries on the mask operas of China, had made a promise to film a certain performer that claimed to be the greatest singer of one of the greatest of songs, entitled, "Riding Alone for Thousands of Miles", from the famed opera, "Romance of the Three Kingdoms". Takada wants to do the film that his son intended, mostly as a way to show how much he truly loves him, despite their not having spoken in years. Despite not knowing a word of Chinese (he employees some interpreters to assist), and being wholly unfamiliar with the customs of the land, Takada remains tenacious in his pursuit of filming the song as a gesture of his love and remorse for the years wasted in isolation.

It's a touching and unpretentious story, never lapsing into the overt manipulation that films of its ilk are prone to do, always staying true to the characters and their interests. While the story itself yields no real surprises, that's just the way life works sometimes, and Yimou's style never falls into the trap of forcing things just to try to punch up dialogue or contrive tearjerker elements just to make the film seem weighty. He keeps his sights modest, and stays on that level, reaping big rewards when the story finishes in a bittersweet fashion.

The ironies of the story are perhaps the most realized of the elements. It's interesting to see a man that barely communicates with people in his own native country, and one that never communicates with his own son, must now find a way to communicate with a variety of people that cannot understand him. All of this to create something that will allow Takada to communicate to his son, except his chosen form of communication is not through his own words, but through the symbolic gesture of the film he film he is trying to make.

The symbolism is readily apparent throughout, as are the many parallels between the relationships between fathers and sons, but these enhance the overall story rather than fall into the realm of artifice just for art's sake. With understated finesse, Yimou keeps his story simple yet his themes complex, richly rewarding those that pay attention to the craftsmanship by which he has developed his soft and solemn tale. Fans that enjoyed his more humanistic works, like Not One Less and The Road Home will find Riding Alone for Thousands of Miles to be a welcome return to form.

-Vince Leo
http://www.qwipster.net/

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!




CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from Riding Alone For Thousands Of Miles at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!