Where A Good Man Goes: Viewer Comments

Viewer Comments Viewer Comments:
Where A Good Man Goes
All Content Used With Permission.


TIP: Log In to enable enhanced Interact features.NEED HELP?

    by City On Fire
    www.cityonfire.com


This movie certainly paints a picture of female goodness that we all need or long for. Lau Ching Wan plays a hard-headed stubborn gangster just released from jail. After finding a place in a local inn, he slowly realizes that the only truthful point in life is nothing more than being cared for and caring for others. Excellent acting once again is offered by Lau Ching Wan and Ruby Wong Cheuk-Ling.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by City On Fire
    www.cityonfire.com




A couple of years ago I had watched Johnny To's "Where A Good Man Goes" and naturally my expectations were up...way up. I ended up disappointed. You see, my mind was already soaked with the string of fantastic films by Milkyway Image, a company that seemed like it specialized in nothing but quality gangster tales and top-notch crime thrillers; even the soundtracks seemed very original and Hollywood-like (you gotta admit, the best thing about Hollywood films these days are their soundtracks). Face it, not one single Hong Kong studio has developed a series of solid, back-to-back films like Milkyway has. Films like "Beyond Hypothermia", "Too Many Ways to Be Number One", "The Odd Ones Dies", "Expect The unexpected", "The Longest Nite" and one of my favorites of all time, "A Hero Never Dies". All these films released between the years 1996 to 1999, then the year 2000 hit - leaving us with the remarkable "Fulltime Killer". Today, Milkyway Image has taken a turn for more mainstream, family orientated films like "Love On A Diet" and "My Left Eye Sees Ghosts". Why? Well, only Johnny To knows (head of Milkyway Image, along with Wa Ka Fai)... but that's another story.

As I said (before I got into lesson one of "Milkyway Films 101"), I was disappointed with "Where A Good Man Goes". Recently, I decided to re-watch the film and get a second opinion? This time around, appreciated it much more. The appreciation probably came from the fact that the Hong Kong film industry is seriously lacking in the gangster/crime genre. Come to think of it, even steady action films or good dramas are almost nowhere to be found. So basically, this is one of those instances of "You don't know what you have until you lost it". In this case, that might be stretching it, but then again, I went from practically hating this film, to liking it. Besides, it's nice to see Lau Ching Wan play a gangster for one of the last times in his career before the "ghosts" and "bra designers" kicked in.

The film's plot centers on Michael (Lau Ching Wan), an ex-gang leader who has just been released from prison. On the first night of freedom, he instantly pisses a taxi driver off, this causes the driver to physically attack him. Out of self defense, Michael takes on the taxi driver - this little duel turns into a "one vs. many" rumble when the cabbie's co-workers pull up and join in on the beating. Victoriously, Michael takes them all on and shows 'em who's bad. After the fight , the barely-injured Michael notices a hotel which he decides to stay in for the night. The hotel is owned by a struggling widow named Siu (played by the underrated Ruby Wong) and her young son. Both had just witnessed Michael's violent encounter with the taxi drivers, this causes a natural, but sweet, tension between them and Michael.

During Michael's first night at the hotel, he immediately feels warm and at home. Despite Michael's temper tantrums, Siu treats him as if he were a VIP, offering services she wouldn't normally do which includes getting him cigarettes and making him meals even though the hotel's restaurant is defunct. Even when an asshole cop (played by Lam Suet) tries to blame Michael for starting the "taxi" brawl, Siu stands up for him. It's during this time that Michael grows for Siu and her son with a feeling he's never felt before - a feeling of having a woman that truly cares, and a son who looks up to him as a father-figure.

The plot thickens as Siu's hotel is in the state of being repossessed by the bank, due to her constant financial hardship. Now that the hotel is sort of a "home" for Michael, he takes action and decides to help Siu financially by hitting the streets and getting back what he once had: money, and lots of it.

As he hustles the streets, Michael realizes that he had lost his power, mostly while he was serving time in prison. His old gang mates are now helpless hoodlums, his partners have fucked him over in shares, and his bitchy ex-girlfriend took all his money while he was in the cell. What makes matters even worse is the asshole cop responsible for putting him behind bars is watching his every move, so committing a crime isn't exactly the best thing to do at the moment, or is it? Deep down inside, Michael must choose between reviving his life of crime and taking whatever penalties it may hold; or he must learn to accept that his successful days of gangsterism are now gone. In between all this is Siu, her son, and a hotel that they're about to lose.

"Where A Good Man Goes" is a gangster film that's high on human drama, and low on violence. It's a heartfelt film about about changing your life, and letting go of the past - no matter how much you loved it. Look out for fine performances by the two leads as well as a superb "love to hate him" role by Lam Suet.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Thomas Shin

A courageous attempt for change. From the familiar traditional hero to an end-of-century good man, the turnaround reminds us of Loving You, although the approach of small-scale drama, with its small hotel feel, is even more peaceful than the previous film. The film focuses on the warmth of the family, small things like a bowl of noodles, a dinner and the tidying up of a room. Johnnie To returns to the simple pleasures of the family, which gel with the exoticism of Macau, which becomes the paradise where a man with a past can find comfort and escape. Such simplicity is also a reflection on the new hero. A man's code may require him to take bullets for other men, but to find happiness for one's love is the real essence of heroes. There is no such thing as self-respect that cannot be discarded, only love that must not be given up.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Po Sharp

We can see in this film Johnnie To's persistent pursuit of a certain woman's image. From Maggie Cheung in The Bare-Footed Kid to Carmen Lee in Loving You to Where a Good Man Goes, his ideal woman/wife is a quiet but strong-willed woman who uses action rather than words to express her love. They are women who do not abandon their men in times of crisis. But this type of love is essentially derived from male friendship. That's why the romantic love in To's films is often violently passionate and rearely tender.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Manalone Ho

There may be no turning back, but sometimes one has to go back to the basics. The new film by Johnnie To and Wai Kar-fai is a work about the collective mentality that results from the economic crisis. With no money and no followers, the best way to rehabilitate is to return to family and kindness. But men can never themselves of such habits as "being the big shot" and "easy money, easy women." They thought violence can solve everything. To overcome difficulties, the woman's approach of finding strength in quiet patience is still the most resilient. Ruby Wong's determination to create a family eventually forces the stubborn tough guy to turn a new page in life. The optimistic ending signals the change in direction in To and Wai's creative direction.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!