Heroes Among Heroes: Viewer Comments

Viewer Comments Viewer Comments:
Heroes Among Heroes
All Content Used With Permission.


TIP: Log In to enable enhanced Interact features.NEED HELP?

    by JH52875


This is not Donnie Yen's best movie but has some nice fighting scenes for die-hard fans like me. The humor is kind of cheesy at times, as in so many of these older HK movies, but overall it is a Donnie/Wo-Ping project and that means nice fighting for sure. I would only recommend this to die-hard fans of the genre, actors and director.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by ET9785


I am a big fan of Donnie; and let me tell you, this movie has good fighting scenes.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by City On Fire
    www.cityonfire.com




A sluggish misfire from acclaimed director and martial arts choreographer Yuen Wo-Ping (with the, uh, assistance of Chan Chin Chung) dealing with fine, upstanding Chinese trying to put an end to the opium trade in their beloved country. Sound like Tai Chi II? It is, but Heroes Among Heroes came first and, in my opinion, is the lesser of the two movies. Furthermore, the gap in quality between this and Yuen Wo-Ping's other, more well-known period kung/wire fu films...Wing Chun, Iron Monkey, and The Tai-Chi Master...is even bigger.

Donnie Yen stars as So Chan, a member of the beggar clan (even though his dad is rich) who gets hooked on opium by a corrupt official and finds himself at odds with the heroic Wong Fei Hung (played, this time, by Wong Gok). The large supporting cast includes Sheila Chan, sporting a very fake-looking set of buck teeth, as Aunt Jean, a character so annoying that you'll want to skip every scene with her in it. Then there's Yiteh, So Chan's love interest and a sort of predecessor to Christy Chung's Tai Chi II character; far too big a deal is made of the fact that she has studied abroad and she tries to improve women's education in China while wearing an ugly hat. Far more interesting, as female characters go, are the women of The Red Lotus Cult, who casually start cutting people to ribbons whenever things don't go their way.

The whole thing resembles nothing so much as a combination martial arts/classroom drug scare film. So Chan's ignorance regarding the insidiousness of opium and the ease with which he succumbs to addiction result in him making a half-assed...no, ONE QUARTER-assed attempt to murder Wong Fei Hung ("Assassinator!", he yells), who is pushing a newfangled pill that eases the quitting process. Naturally, he sees the error of his ways after being sealed up in a drugless room (a la Trainspotting, but without the baby on the ceiling) and joins the anti-opium crusade soon enough. Straightforward battle is eschewed in favor of gimmick fights, like a seated duel involving an opium pipe (Wong Guk's hand catches fire, but he doesn't seem to mind) and a Red Lotus Cult member lashing out with her deadly ponytail (yet another Tai Chi II parallel).

Heroes Among Heroes is definitely one of Yuen Wo-Ping's lesser films, both as a director and a choreographer. The highlight is So Chan's dad indicating Aunt Jean and saying, "Look, she's just like a bitch." Little of the greatness displayed in Iron Monkey and The Tai-Chi Master (both of which were also 1993 productions...two out of three ain't bad, I guess) can be seen here. It's not as much of a bummer as the D.T.s, but still unworthy of high praise.

AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
NGranted its not the best Yuen Wo-Ping film, but I did not think it was as bad as you point out in your review. Its more of a 3 star movie, it has its problems but Donnie Yen is still entertaining in the lead role.Sgt. T
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Sydneyguy

The VCD I got actually had "Hero among Heroes" so I was wondering what this movie was!! This is your standard kung fu movie. this time, instead of Wong Fei Hung being the central character, it's Beggar Su, who was brought up by the leader of the beggar group. Beggar Su's father thought this would teach him humility. There is plenty of good fighting scenes with little blood splatted on the TV set. Not a bad effort.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Ash


Heroes Among Heroes is another kung fu movie from the master: Yuen Wo Ping. It stars Donnie Yen (the greatest in my opinion!) As usual, Yen kicks some major butts in this movie but the story is not really original: Opium dealing involving the ''evil'' British!! (Strongly reminiscent of Drunken Master 2, Tai Chi 2 or even Once Upon A Time In China!!) The actor who portrays Wong Fei Hung in the movie is also a good martial artist; but Donnie, once again, steals the show with his grace and his charisma. He even uses the drunken style in this movie. There is a good amount of fights in this movie but they are short but the climactic fight is great. Watch this movie for the fights, not for the story, because the fights are from Yuen Wo Ping, and Donnie Yen shines, as always!! 7.8/10
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!