Harakiri: Reviews

Reviews Reviews:
Harakiri
All Content Used With Permission.


TIP: Log In to enable enhanced Interact features.NEED HELP?

    by Criterion

ALTERNATE SYNOPSIS:
Following the collapse of his clan, unemployed samurai Hanshiro Tsugumo (Tatsuya Nakadai) arrives at the manor of Lord Iyi, begging to commit ritual suicide on his property. Iyi’s clansmen, believing the desperate ronin is merely angling for charity, try to force him to eviscerate himself—but they have underestimated his honor and his past. Winner of the 1963 Cannes Film Festival’s Special Jury Prize, Masaki Kobayashi’s Harakiri is a scathing denouncement of feudal authority and hypocrisy.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Opus Zine
    www.opuszine.com



In the early 17th century, Japan's Shogunate government has begun cracking down on many of the smaller Houses and Clans, abolishing them with little rhyme or reason. As a result, thousands of people are left without any livelihood, and many samurai are now wandering the countryside as ronin, or masterless warriors. Some try to eke out a living the best they can, but many others, concerned with their honor, seek to commit harakiri, or ceremonial suicide.

One such man, Hanshiro, appears at the gates of the honorable Iyi Clan's castle, asking that they provide him with the facilities necessary to commit harakiri. Although suspicious at first, since many other ronin in a similar situation have tried to blackmail the clan for some money or a new job, Hanshiro manages to convince them that he really does wish to commit harakiri. While waiting for the arrangements to be made, the head of the Clan recounts a similar story that took place earlier that year.

Another ronin, Chijiiwa, appeared at their gates with a request similar to Hanshiro's. But unlike Hanshiro, he lacked the resolve to go through with it. What's more, Chijiiwa's status as a samurai was even doubtful to begin with; he carried bamboo swords, something no true samurai would do. Ultimately, Chijiiwa is forced to commit harakiri in order to prove his honor, and in the film's most shocking scene, disembowels himself with his bamboo blade.

After Chijiiwa's story is done, Hanshiro prepares to go through with his ceremony. But before he does, he tells his story, one that is inextricably linked with Chijiiwa's. At first, it's the tale of a poor, clan-less warrior trying to eke out a life for himself, his daughter, and the son of his best friend. But soon, it becomes a scathing indictment of the cruelty and harshness of bushido, the samurai code of honor.

Although the samurai strive to be paragons of honor and virtue, compassion and mercy are beneath them, and they have nothing but contempt for those who don't match their lofty standards. But that contempt masks hypocrisy - samurai are still human after all, with all of the normal failings and weaknesses - and as Hanshiro's story comes to an end, the truth about the "honorable" Iyi Clan is revealed.

While perhaps not as recognizable as Toshiro Mifune, Tatsuya Nakadai was one of Japan's greatest samurai actors, appearing films like "Sword Of Doom", "Sanjuro", and "Samurai Rebellion". Nakadai absolutely owns "Harakiri" from beginning to end, delivering a riveting and gripping performance as Hanshiro. At first, he seems to be a common warrior looking to save face, but as the movie goes on, his aura grows deadlier and more menacing as he exposes the Iyi Clan for what it truly is.

Those expecting some crazy hack n' slash adventure like "Shogun Assassin" might be disappointed with "Harakiri". The film moves pretty fairly slowly at times, especially with the constant flashbacks, but it's not long before you find yourself totally drawn in. The dialog might seem too melodramatic at times, even silly, especially when characters praise the virtues of a proper disembowelment and debate the meaning of honor with flowery dialog and grim expressions. But that's the point. By comparing such scenes with the samurais' cold and callous actions, it exposes their hypocrisy. It's hard to call someone honorable when they compliment a man for using the proper disembowelment technique while, in the next room, his sickly child lay dying.

The film inevitably marches towards a final showdown, and all of the tension and bitterness just explodes in the movie's final 15 minutes or so. Again, Nakadai is just amazing to watch. There's a steely glint in his eyes that's riveting, and when he marches towards his opponents, with his arms crossed across his chest and katana ready to strike... well, let's just say his foe(s) are going to need some clean drawers... if their heads are still attached to their bodies, that is.

"Harakiri" may not be as famous as Kurosawa and Mifune's samurai pictures, but it's a great one nonetheless, well worth the time spent seeking it out (I'd love to see this reissued on DVD). While films like Mifune's "Samurai" trilogy espouse the glories of bushido and how it can help a cruel, base man find honor and decency, "Harakiri" exposes bushido's dark side. "Harakiri"'s samurai are not noble men. Rather, they are men who follow bushido instead of their conscience, instead of their heart. Their sense of honor is nothing more than a veneer, a way to justify dishonorable, and even evil actions. The film's final scene chillingly drives home that idea. There is no happy ending, but simply a warning against the evil that can be done, all in the name of honor and righteousness.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Acquarello



The retainer log book for the Official Residence of Lord Iyi reports that at midday on an otherwise uneventful day on the thirteenth of May 1630, during the absence of the Honorable Heir Bennosuke, a gaunt, former retainer of the Lord of Geishu arrives at the mansion gates and is granted an interview with the Iyi clan elder, Saito Kayegu (Rentaro Mikuni). The solemn and enigmatic ronin (masterless samurai), Tsugumo Hanshiro (Tatsuya Nakadai), has led a dire life of poverty since the abolition of the Geishu clan in 1619, and now expresses his desire to die with dignity and commit harakiri (ritual disembowelment) in the sanctity of warlord grounds. However, in an era of peace with few employment prospects for samurai in the dwindling local feudal clans that were allowed to remain after the centralization of power by the Tokugawa shogunate, the request has become commonplace. Spurred by reports of generosity and benevolence towards the destitute ronins among the surviving clans, many desperate samurai have insincerely requested admission to commit harakiri with the expectation of being turned away with a small pittance. Saito cautions Tsugumo against making such a request, citing a pathetic and tragic incident involving another Geishu retainer, Chijiwa Motome (Akira Ishihama), who insincerely threatened harakiri as a ruse to obtain charity, and was compelled by the Iyi retainers to carry out the agonizing ritual using only a bamboo blade - the empty tokens of his privileged class pawned long ago to provide for his family. Undeterred, Tsugumo reaffirms his determination to perform the sacred act of seppuku (the disembowelment ritual performed in the presence of a second officiate swordsman who carries out the final head cutting), and requests the services of swordsman, Omodaka Hikokuro (Tetsuro Tamba), to act as his second officiate. Upon learning that Omodaka has taken a leave of absence, Tsugumo names two other Iyi retainers to carry out the task, Kawabe Umenosuke (Yoshio Aoki), then Yazaki Hayato (Ichirô Nakaya), to no avail. As Tsugumo waits for the indisposed retainers, he proceeds to recount the story of his disillusioned life that led to this fateful day.

Based on a novel by Yasuhiko Takiguchi, Harakiri is a scathing indictment on the hypocrisy, repression, and barbarism of codified behavior. Using rigid rectangular framing against fluid tracking shots and exquisitely composed long shots that delineate class station and social disparity, Masaki Kobayashi visually reflects the oppressive confinement and regimentation of the samurai bushido (code of conduct): the title sequence presented against shots of the empty passageways that lead to the sacred chamber of the Iyi clan's ancestral armor; the isolating, diagonal shots of Saito's interviews with Tsugumo and Chijiwa; the repeated image of Tsugumo on a ceremonial mat encircled by retainers. By illustrating the class stratification and imposed social conformity fostered by the Tokugawa shogunate (1600-1867) as a means of retaining and centralizing authority, Kobayashi presents a harrowing indictment of the ingrained cultural legacy of coercive, outmoded rituals, chauvinism, and blind obedience that resulted in the inhumanity and senseless tragedy of the Pacific War.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!