Have Sword, Will Travel: Viewer Comments

Viewer Comments Viewer Comments:
Have Sword, Will Travel
All Content Used With Permission.


TIP: Log In to enable enhanced Interact features.NEED HELP?

    by RM52330


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by William Giordanella


Solid film starring Ti Lung and David Chiang and to my surprise Chiang's performance was a little better than Lung's. I also thought Ku Feng was very good (no surprise there) but I thought overall the story dragged a little in a few places and this could have used a little more action to propel it to true greatness. More story driven than action driven but definitely worth a look.
AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YXslaveX
Ycorrect rating and accurate points.Adam helfrich
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Adam helfrich




"Have Sword Will Travel" is one of the earlier efforts from the famed team of Chang Cheh, Ti Lung, and David Chiang. Some people consider this to be a landmark film that help popularize the American western culture within Hong Kong cinema and also cemented Ti Lung and David Chiang as a great onscreen duo.

This film is very well-made and often seems to be more focused on character development and relationships than pure action. "Have Sword Will Travel" does feature several action scenes that are often bloody and brutal. Chang Cheh and his action choreographers, Tang Chia and Yuen Cheung Yan, did a great job delivering quality action scenes within the narrative.

"Have Sword Will Travel" also features some very strong acting. If I had to list three of the best pure actors from the Shaw studio, Ti Lung, David Chiang, and Ku Feng would be among the top of the list. Some people may not be that high on Chiang and some of his stiff and emotionless acting, but I think it can be very effective. In the case of this film, I thought he was great as the poor loner that never wanted help from anyone possessing just enough mystique and charisma to attract Ti Lung's girlfriend (Li Ching). Ti Lung is also great and did a nice job playing the suspicious and jealous martial arts master. Finally, not enough can be said about the great Ku Feng. The more Shaw Brothers films you watch the more you realize this guy was in nearly everything. Ku Feng is a vetern of over 300 films and always does a great job whether he is a magician in "Black Magic" or a robber and head of a gang in "Have Sword Will Travel".

My only complaint with the film is that the pacing was a bit slow and a few scenes dragged longer than what was neccessary, but even still....

Highly recommended!

AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YI wouldn't quite go to "Highly recommended," but this is pretty good. Ti Lung seemed quite young, and would soon be more authoritative: David Chiang is his usual self.Jeffrey Frawley
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by XslaveX




A swordplay movie about some security bureau would must tranfer gold somewhere. Some evil Tiger Gang wants to acquire the loot. Some lone wolf swordman (Chiang) gets involved and is infatuated with some broad and Ti Lung is jealous and all sorts of shit happens. I know, I can't explain stories without being a dick.

The film is typical Chang Cheh bloodshed happiness with a predictable plotline and plentiful bloodshed action. But with a film like this I pay more attention to characterization and I love the character in this film. I love the idea that some gives themselves a name that expresses a high level of infamy like Pestilence. Uh, I get orgasms everytime I witness this crap. I love character names over the commonplace crap. "It's Bill. He's gonna rape us." THAT SUCKS! "It's walrus Testicles. He's gonna slaughter us." PERFECT!!!!!!

[Spoilers] The film does fail in certain aspects if you do nit-pick at every detail of a film. The pacing is a bit slow and a few scenes just drag on tediously like the prolongation of the final scene where we see David Chiang trying to crawl away from the entropy and it's like 8 mintues. Also the pre-meditation scene before the final bout. It kills the pacing and the consistency of the film a little but not by much and could be considered incoherent depending on the viewer. But still this bloodshed at it's finest and I am just estatic when it comes to Chang Cheh bloodshed film.

Concept: 3 1/2 (out of 5) - Nothing you haven't seen before but still the story works well.

Execution: 4 (out of 5) - The fights were great but a few of the scenes drags and it kills the consistent flow.

Fairness: BLOODSHED!!!!!!

Conclusion: I'm gonna have an erection over any Chang Cheh bloodshed film no matter what so take that, SUCKAZZZZZ! :)

AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YI agree that some scenes dragged but I enjoyed the bloodshed and storyAdam helfrich
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by VC58819


Another classic movie of yesteryear. A must-see film for lovers of this genre.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by ST56022


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by AE24151


Good action, but I've seen better.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by LG43358


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Roger Judd, Jr.


Great film and excellent performances by David Chiang and Ti Lung. Maybe not their best, but above average. Ku Feng is also good in this one. Good storyline and good fights. You can't go wrong with this one.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by HG6505


Great movie. It's amazing how much you see this movie's influence on the western classic "Shane". Ti Lung really stole the show from Chiang, in my opinion.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Jeffrey Frawley


Some of David Chiang's charm escapes me, but he is well cast as a swordsman whose motives and allegiances are initially unclear. Ti Lung, as a righteous swordsman who distrusts Chiang, seems slightly young and less authoritative than he would soon become, but both he and Chiang give rather good performances. Chang Cheh's interest in masculine brotherhood, to the exclusion of traditional love affairs, is already firmly established here, giving a clear indication of his future direction.

This isn't one of the best from Chang Cheh, David Chiang or Ti Lung, but it is entertaining and very much worth viewing.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by DongFangSue


Not many of the films shot at the end of the 60's and in the beginning of the 70's are entertaining enough to satisfy the taste of kung fu movie fans these days. This is a good one.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by VP1698


Wonderful!

I love David Chiang in this movie.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by 100pr00f
    Wutang-corp.com


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Peter Schneider


A really classic. Chang Cheh teams up the former stuntman david chiang und ti lung. The fights are bloody and well performed. Shot 1969 it shows the ways shaw brothers focus on the action.

There some gritty fights, so don't look, if you searching for a comedy.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by City On Fire
    www.cityonfire.com




An early Chang Cheh movie from the days when choreography wasn't all that hot and Hong Kong cinema was still getting on its feet, Have Sword, Will Travel is nevertheless an entertaining martial arts film. I've always felt that Chang Cheh was a better director in his early movies (though I enjoy his later films more, if that makes any sense), and here his directorial skill is in full effect.

David Chiang plays a sullen drifter obviously inspired by Clint Eastwood's character in the Sergio Leone films. All Chiang has is his sword and his horse, which he apparently is in love with. Ti Lung and Li Ching are swordfighters who happen to be engaged, and also are the head enforcers of an escort agency (the type that protects cargo shipments). Their teacher is ill and can't use his kung-fu, so there's all sorts of worry going on, because the agency has been hired to transport a huge amount of money, and word is the Flying Tiger Stockade gang, headed by the purely evil Ku Feng, is out for it.

The majority of the movie deals with Chiang's interactions with Ti Lung and Li Ching, as a love triangle develops. For whatever reason, Li gets all tingly over the large-eared, snaggle-toothed Chiang. This of course pisses off Ti Lung, so he and Chiang engage in all sorts of challenges. While this is going on, Ku Feng keeps an eye on the escort agency, trying to figure out who the mysterious Chiang is. Feng sends out his top two henchmen: The Pestilence and The Mute, the latter played by Wang Chung, who by the way is probably the coolest-looking character in the movie. Whereas most of the other characters wear costuming you'd expect from older, more traditional martial arts films, Wang wears the type of outfit you'd expect to see in a latter-day Venoms movie, complete with studded armbands. His character is in fact mute, so all he can do is utter unintentionally-hilarious grunts. The quick fights with these two characters provide the movie with its only mortal combat until the blood-drenched finale.

The problem with the movie is that the escort agency knows Ku Feng is out for the money they're transporting. They also know that Ku Feng lurks in a towering pagoda that sits along the route they'll take. So this of course begs the question: why don't they just take a different route? This is never addressed, the escort instead just plodding along to the pagoda, which is infested with swarthy henchmen who are out for their blood.

Chiang of course ends up joining the agency, only because he secretly feels the same for Li Ching. Once he discovers her teacher is sick and can't protect her on the journey, he wants to be there. Chiang was Cheh's early favorite, so he makes him a veritable god when it comes to fighting and swordplay. Despite Chiang's obvious lack of swordfighting skill, he hacks down innumerable foes, with Ti Lung, the better martial artist, providing a supporting role. The film's internal and external plots come together during the great final reel, with a full-on massacre and battle at Ku Feng's pagoda. Those expecting Chang's requisite tragic ending will not be disappointed.

The movie isn't as bloody as later Chang Cheh films, or even a few that came before it, such as Golden Swallow or Return of the One-Armed Swordsman. All of the real violence is saved for the end, where we are treated to slow-motion shots of blood erupting from sliced stomachs, arrows puncturing flesh, and swords dicing through opponents. The choreography doesn't hide the actors' lack of martial arts skill, though Ti Lung, Ku Feng, and Wang Chung come off as naturals. The fights here are pretty quick, in fact, just a few sword strokes and that's it. This makes the movie come off as more of a traditional swordplay piece, even like a samurai film, than your average kung-fu movie. I'm not saying it's worse, just different.

Of special interest is that the end of the film features Lung and Chiang battling their way to the top of the martial artist-filled pagoda. Hey, wait a second: that's the same ending Bruce Lee proposed for his original Game of Death! But before you cry foul, consider this: Have Sword, Will Travel was released a full three years before Bruce began work on his project. Hmm. I can just see the headlines now: "Was Bruce Lee the Quentin Tarantino of his day?"

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!