Clean My Name, Mr. Coroner!: Reviews

Reviews Reviews:
Clean My Name, Mr. Coroner!
All Content Used With Permission.


TIP: Log In to enable enhanced Interact features.NEED HELP?

    by So Good... - Hong Kong DVD Movie Reviews
    www.sogoodreviews.com



Undercover cop Fred (Nick Cheung from The Conman 1999) gets the go ahead by, his superior Inspector Lau (Ti Lung from Drunken Master II), to go through with a 20 million dollar deal with a gang. The deal turns violent and in the ensuing shootout Fred's partner Herman escapes with the money. Fred flees the scene and tries to catch up with him but he's stopped at a roadblock. The police finds a headless corpse in his trunk which is identified as Herman. Fred now has to go on the run to figure out who's behind this set up of him. He goes to the morgue to inspect the body himslef and drags the unwilling coroner Ko (Francis Ng) into his, now, problemfilled life...

James Yuen's thriller-comedy is very recognizable. The plot has been used and seen before in world cinema, the execution of the movie doesn't raise any bars and the twists in the story are easily figured out even by the most casual viewer. Doesn't sound good at all, right? In my opinion, you CAN make a typical genre movie that holds no surprises and still receive good grades in the end by critics and fans. It's not hard to notice that in many movies there's no real effort behind the scenes but it feels different in Clean My Name, Mr Coroner! It's evident that James is aware of the limits of how high he can aim with this production and I must say that he seems to have achieved what he set out to do.

As the writer of this been there, done that-plot , James doesn't make things difficult for himself in the directing department. The pace is set pretty much right and things move smoothly from scene to scene with plot exposition inserted without stopping the movie completely. Since I didn't know much about the content and how the movie was going to turn out, I thought the beginning seemed a little disjointed. The main plot kicks in fast though and is dealt with in a clear manner. There is even a short shootout for us action junkies that felt way too shaky camera wise but exciting enough still.

When Fred and Ko eventually start to dominate the movie, the familiar buddy movie aspect enters. Nick Cheung and Francis Ng's banter won't rival pairs like Nick Nolte-Eddie Murphy or Mel Gibson-Danny Glover but their contrast in character make for some amusing scenes. It's especially fun when Ko has to let Fred, a real slacker compared to the tidy Ko, take refuge in his home. You can almost feel Ko panicking inside when he's very planned out way of living is disrupted by the less tidy cop. Again, the sitautions and themes regarding these characters has been done before but I won't complain when it's well done. There's a few thriller moments inserted and James Yuen moves professionally between that and the comedy. He creates a good tension with dramatic lighting and tilted camera angles in combination with a simple but effective score. I would've been more happy if he had choosen to straighten up the camera for certain dialogue scenes though. It draws far too much attention to itself when we're watching dialogue in a 45 degree tilt. There's also some uses of steady cam in the street chase for example but the way it's done here just annoys me. I don't feel that blurry motion is the right choice in this case and I'm betting the chase could've been better if we had gotten a good look at what was happening. Director Wong Kar-Wai makes it work in some of his movies but it's there for a purpose which certain directors doesn't seem to get.

To make Clean My Name, Mr Coroner! and it's main core, the comedy, to work you have to have actors that can generate the chemistry needed. Nick Cheung provides a solid turn and displayed the anger needed for his character. When he went in his comedy mode, he handles it calmly which works with what's written. There's a few scenes where shouting is employed to create comedy and it's just not something I find funny. The character lacks some things in the writing but as an actor Nick Cheung does his job well on this movie. Whether there's room for improvement remains to be seen.

One of my favourite actors from the Shaw Brother's era, Ti Lung, is still going strong. During the 80s he proved once and for all that he had crossed over from martial arts actor to character actor through such films as A Better Tomorrow and People's Hero. There's not a lot of surprises to his character Lau in this movie but Ti Lung never gets dull to look at, no matter what movie he's in. Stephanie Che is nice eye-candy for the production but her inclusion as the romantic interest for one of the characters does feel out of place. We could've lost that character and still had a movie but I guess there have to something there for us guys. Wilson Yip fan's should also keep an eye out for the charismatic Joe Lee.

Not surprisingly the biggest shining star of Clean My Name, Mr Coroner! is Francis Ng. He's been on a roll now for a few years, making only a few bad movies along the way, and has also directed two movies (9413 and What Is A Good Teacher?). Here he adds another layer to his already present versatility in his portrayal of the slightly odd coroner Ko. He's born into a rich family and has a very scheudled way of living his life. When Fred comes along that all breaks down though but he's smart enough to eventually adjust since he's also in danger. His odd nature could've been something that had been shaped through his profession but it's just who he is. Smart, methodic and good at what he does are traits that the character have but that also applies to Francis Ng's acting skills.

In the end James Yuen's Clean My Name, Mr Coroner! is a good thriller-comedy. It doesn't aim high in terms of originality but instead hits the level of quality it's after. Whether or not you're a Francis Ng fan, this movie will provide you with solid entertainment.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by John Richards



In a change from his usual cool tough guy type roles Francis Ng appears as the rather eccentric coroner of the title. The bow tie wearing, mild mannered Keith leads a strictly ordered life that is shattered when undercover cop Fred (Nick Cheung), framed for the murder of his partner, crashes in.

When a mutilated corpse is found in the trunk of Fred's car everybody assumes that it is his missing partner and Fred has committed murder and taken a suitcase of money that was in the two cops' care. Forced to go on the run Fred takes Keith hostage and forces him to collaborate to try and clear his name (hence the title).

Unfortunately Fred is the victim of a conspiracy and those behind it are not prepared to leave any loose ends. Fred and Keith must solve the mystery while evading capture by the police or death at the hands of the villains. Luckily they have an ally in a bar worker (Stephanie Che) who offers them sanctuary in her appartment and later helps them in their investigations.

Since early appearances in 'Young and Dangerous' and as the dark brooding villain of Ringo Lam's 'Full Alert', Francis Ng has been a name to look out for. Further roles in thrillers like 'The Mission', '2000AD' and, more recently, 'A War Named Desire' have really made him one of Hong Kong cinema's brightest hopes. Here he shows a different side to the usual tough guy character (be it cop or gangster) in an altogether geeky role but carries it off with ease.

Nick Cheung, an actor who I usually find quite annoying with the 'Chow Sing Chi copycat' thing that he does, is also good here with a much more understated and serious role. He really should try more things like this. Ti Lung is as solid as ever and Stephanie Che also puts in a good performance providing more than just eye candy for the lads.

With a sharp script, engaging storyline and brilliant performances from just about everybody, 'Clean My Name...' is definately a cut above director James Yuen's previous offering 'My Loving Trouble 7'. While maintaining a fresh look Yuen hasn't seen fit to resort to the MTV style (over content) of movie making that seems so prominent these days. The film is well paced with a coherent plot and time is taken to develop both story and characters. The emphasis is definitely on plot though rather than action; there is very little action in this movie.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!