 |  |  |  |  Fantastic supernatural love story between man and ghost. True it has been done before numerous times, especially in the Hong Kong film world, but this one really does go the extra mile with mummies, mile long tongues, a finale that defies description, and plenty of slime. In my opinion Ma Wu steals the show as the gruff Taoist who breaks into song. A true classic that seriously needs a modern DVD. | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  This movie isn't that bad. It influences a lot of Chinese traditional music. And perhaps it is one of the best Chinese movies that I have saw so far. This is a good movie. | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  I like this film, the story was well thought out and it was well directed. The acting was good too. But the thing I liked most was the feeling the film created by the music and images. Looking for a enjoyable film get this, if you're looking for martial arts don't. | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  | 
| Cult favorite HK films are a hit-or-miss bunch. Mr. Vampire, there's a hit. Marvelous film, loads of fun. Naked Killer, there's a miss. Horrible film, no fun at all. And now, A Chinese Ghost Story, which, having two options, I guess I would count as a hit, albeit a rather weak one aimed at a non-vital area.
Leslie Cheung is Ning Tsai-Shen, a traveling something-or-other who spends a night at a supposedly haunted temple. He meets Tsing, a ghost with whom...this being a fantasy...he falls in love. Poor bastard. Little does he realize that Tsing is (unwillingly) part of a spectral sisterhood that lures wicked, evil males (meaning all men except our good-natured protagonist) to their doom. The leader of this group is a tree-monster with a giant, slimy tongue that rampages through the woods in search of victims to devour. There's also a Taoist swordsman (Wu Ma) who, with his one mystic incantation that seems to accomplish pretty much anything, seeks to rid the world of the living of these vicious spirits (when he's not starring in little one-man music videos, that is).
I've never been impressed with Joey Wang's limited acting abilities before and I'm not impressed with them now, but she seems like a good choice for the role of Tsing; she's got the wide-eyed innocent look down pat. Leslie Cheung and Wu Ma are certainly serviceable, but not extraordinary.
The film's few attempts at humor...such as overzealous guards who spring into action whenever a villager says "Don't go away" and an overplayed scene in which Tsing must conceal Ning in a bathtub...fall flat. The action sequences have that high-flying Ching Siu-Tung hyperkineticism, which is very much a love it or hate it kind of thing and clashes uncomfortably with the somewhat methodical pace of Ning's attempts to befriend Tsing (it seems like he visits the temple more often than necessary). And while the sets and morbid-looking props are impressive (the film gets an A for visual style), the special effects are quite antiquated, and the "Black King"...a suit of armor surrounded by smoke with a movable jawpiece...was laughable before the movie was even made.
This isn't a badly put-together film, and I don't begrudge it its popularity, but it didn't do much for me, personally. Actually, the main reason I watched it is because Harvey Weinstein doesn't want me to. Just my little way of kicking dirt on the fat fuck's shoes.
That said...next up: A Chinese Ghost Story 2! |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |
| What fun! This film is a treat from all those clone/western stories with the same, run down plot and tired vampires who's teeth get longer as they age! At least this story has a great plot--love can last beyond the grave---and in discovering this our hero meets up with all kinds of spooky creatures. (The giant tongue is particularly eerie). There are the usual sort of zombies shown in a fashion unique and at times funny. The main 'ghost' is a strange blend of Coppola's Dracula and a bad hair day. Yes, there are beautiful maidens, magic swords, books and, of course, our poor hero who's shunned because he's sent into town to collect debts. (Seems like the villagers have a way of disposing of debt collectors by suggesting they stay at the local, haunted temple---if only our lives were so easy!) Through all this is a maiden our hero falls for whom is seen only at night and protects him from those bent on doing him harm. (Sometimes her protection has moments of laughter). For a ghost story this has all the elements you'd expect---including humor, threats, struggle and a not-sure-how-this-will-end. Guaranteed you'll never think of 'blood buns' the same again! Highly recommended. |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  | | Extremely entertaining. Though I watched it when I was only 12, I was very much moved by the love affair between Xiao Qian and Ning Cai Cheng. Even now, after 10 years, I am still captivated by the exchange between the two leads. The Taoist priest of course provided much comic relief to the movie as well, which of course adds to the list of watchables in the movie. I would also highly recommand the soundtrack, "May Dawn Never Come" [transliteration], which of course won the Golden Horse Award in 1980s. | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  | 
| Chinese Ghost Story was, I imagine, pretty damn scary way back in 1987 when stop motion animation and guys in rubber suits were still considered advanced special effects. In a dimly lit theater packed with similarly frightened film-goers, CGS probably delivered state of the art thrills at the time. I imagine the audiences approached the movie in much the same way I approached Poltergeist while in grade school, with one hand clasped firmly over my eyes and the other gripping my chair's arm rest. The scene in Poltergeist where the guy peels away layers of his face scared the shit out of me then, just as scenes of wrinkly undead slithering and sliding their way throughout Chinese Ghost Story possibly scared the shit out of Hong Kong audiences in '87. Of course, I could be wrong and they might have been thinking what I was thinking during the film's entire 95 minute running time: "Damn, this movie sucks."
Yes, the film is indeed a ghost story, an atmospheric and humorous one at that. Its attempts at comedy are as frequent as its attempts at horror yet both often fall flat. There's a little bit of wire-fu, although most of the action doesn't involve fights at all, but rather people running up walls and across tree tops. Yawn. There are also far too many scenes of laughably fake animatronic and stop-motion zombies that make the skeletons in the '60s film Jason and the Argonauts look T2:Judgement Day in comparison.
So, if it isn't scary, funny or feature copious amounts of wire-aided action or mayhem, what IS it, exactly? In a word, dull. The best thing that can be said about CGS is that it features slick cinematography and stylish direction by Ching Siu Tung. Producer Tsui Hark's trademark style is also evident here and gives the film a distinct look common to his films. The performances are adequate, including decent turns by Leslie Cheung as a bumbling tax collector and a beautiful Joey Wang as a ghost. There are a couple of enjoyable scenes in the movie that DO elicit genuine laughs yet these are too few and far between to add up to a good time. |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
|