 |  |  |  |  This is a good remake of "The One-Armed Swordsman". Tsui Hark's adaptation just seems fresh and new. The style is nice and the action is really great. I enjoyed this picture a lot. | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  This is an awesome swordplay movie that is both cruel and beautiful. It's a remake of the classic "The One Armed Swordsman" from 1967. Both written and directed by Tsui Hark with Chiu Man Cheuk--who I thought would be the next big superstar of martial arts movies, but he went from movies to TV which kinda' sucks because I think he is a great martial artist and a good screen fighter.
SEE THIS IF YOU HAVEN'T ALREADY. | | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | Y | | JV47842 |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  | 
| [HKFlix Note: This review refers to the PanMedia Version 3 DVD.] I first saw "The Blade" in 1997, on VHS. I will guess that the copy was an original print with full score and subtitles. It was amazing, especially the subtitles. They were done so well, each line was like well written verse, bursting with meaning and opportunity for philosophical interpretation. If you can find that particular copy, please get it and love it.
However, the version I purchased in NOT the version I recall watching a half dozen times. The score volume has been dramatically reduced, and that is a shame. The biggest letdown is the subtitles--for some reason they were redone for this copy of the DVD, and they are terrible. No longer do they explain the story (I pity a first-time viewer who has not seen the original), but all poetic meaning had been stripped away. Truly disappointing.
I highly recommend THE BLADE, but not this version (or printing, or whatever it is called). I wish I could tell you how to discern between the two. The only advice I can give is to get your hands on the first printing VHS, then you can be sure you are getting the real thing. You will be impressed. |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  Tsui Hark is a great director when he has the right material. Mr. Hark does an incredible job in "The Blade", which is actually a loose remake of "The One-Armed Swordsman". "The Blade" has excellent fight scenes and a wonderful epic feeling story. | | AGREE? | READER COMMENTS | AUTHOR | | Y | Great movie! I have always thought the lead actor Chi Man Cheuk was underrated! He does a fantastic job as our one-armed hero. | Sgt. T |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  The reason or reasons I'm giving this one star was due to the plot of revenge I understood, but the in-between desolation, sex, and debauchery was not appealing at all. The action scenes were fine, but that is bascially the only reason for purchasing this film. | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  This in no way resembles the Jackie Chan, Sammo Hung comedy kung fu that seems to make up the bulk of my collection. Very good, almost artsy action drama with a far darker, more serious, hopeless tone edging into "Dog Bite Dog" territory. The action is brutally feral and realistic and completely without any noticeable use of wires, etc. The classic "One Armed Swordsman" revenge story is solid, the acting is good all around, and Chiu Man Cheuk makes a great lead. Recommended! | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  I love this remake of "The One-Armed Swordsman" by Tsui Hark. It has a great story and excellent action, the cast are all very good. If you are a fan of Tsui Hark's, this one is a must! | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  This is super cool! Also, it's not easy to get your hands on a copy of this DVD anywhere else. I had see this after I listened to the commentary on the Dragon Dynasty DVD of "One-Armed Swordsman". Get both, compare and contrast, you won't be disappointed. | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  A dark and whirling maelstrom of martial violence. Vincent Zhao should've been a bigger star based on this performance. Tsui Hark's best film IMO. | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  Watching "The Blade" was a hallucinatory experience. This film is all over the place: frenetic, kinetic, surreal, etc. Ultimately, you come out of the whole experience dazed and definitely spent. To be honest, this film strays pretty far from "The One-Armed Swordsman" so as to not truly qualify as a "remake". Tsui Hark has crafted something totally unique, certainly from a visual standpoint. This is so far ahead of anything else happening in 1995, that it may as well be on another planet. My only complaint is that some of the fight sequences are so sped-up that it seems rather a waste. Overall this grim, dark, and twisted version of the One-Armed Swordsman is required viewing for all wuxia fans, and fans of Tsui Hark's worldview, in particular. | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  I was a bit disappointed with this film because of the pacing of the action and the uneven scenario. The action is hard to explain--it's very fast and it's difficult to clearly see the choreography. But there is something special about the flick, there is a lot of talent in this movie. | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  I caught this movie at a Hong Kong film fest in the 90's. I really dug it. I bought the Jimmy Wang Yu "One Armed Swordsman" box set plus "One Armed Boxer" films while searching for the one I'd seen in the theater. I really enjoyed those of course, but still couldn't find Tsui Hark's "One Armed Swordsman." Little did I know it was simply called "The Blade." Thanks HKFlix for helping me find it! | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  An amazing storyline and top notch action [when there was action]. I would've rated this movie higher if there was a little more martial arts action. One major fight scene isn't enough for a kung fu movie. | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  Awesome "re-imagining" that has very few things in common with the original film. And those elements that are the same look and feel so completely different that you forget you've seen it before. With the trademark of Tsui Hark's amped up action, cool set design and appropriately dirty/clean cinematography and Wing Zhao proving a worthy successor to Wang Yu, "The Blade" is a must have for any Fu-Fan that you will watch more than twice! | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  | 
| In "The Blade", Tsui Hark attempts to break out of the conventions of the traditional martial arts movie, with riveting scenes, but also a few discordant notes.
As I watch this movie, the narrative is carried by the view point of a young girl, which in fact reminded me of Hong Kong romance films. The girl's narrative gives a self-reflexive philosophical commentary about life, growing up, etc. Huh? What is that doing in a martial arts movie, was my first reaction. At the end, I was still unconvinced that it added anything to the story.
Chiu Man-Cheuk is the best part of the movie. He is a great wu shu performer, but also a decent actor, showing more nuances of emotion than Jet Li or Yeun Biao. His presence on the screen displays stylistic violence but not outright brutality. That role is reserved for the villain, Hung Yan Yab, who also does a great job. I only wish there had been more fights between the two.
One discordant note is again the layering of the romantic story on top of the classic revenge plot. Maybe it was saying something deep, but it escaped me. Should I blame the film, or myself?
The action is much more "raw" than most martial arts films, with blood splattering that looks quite real. (not that I would really know) The training sequence, using only one arm, was rather interesting. It would have been fun to see more of it, but the plot wanted to move on. Another discordant note was the weapon used by the bad guy. It was very cool looking, but really, it just looked too advanced for the period of the story. You'll see what I mean when you get to the scene.
What really caused me to drop a rating on this film is the main love interest, who provides the narrative. She is quite simply a poor actress. (is she some popular pop singer?) In too many scenes, it looked like she wanted to laugh when she should have cried. And almost everyone screams out their lines. Maybe they had more hearing problems in those days? |
| | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  A very rare and hard to find film. Simple martial arts story with superb sword fighting technique. A better movie than Shaw Brothers' classic "One Armed Swordsman". | | LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW! |
|  |  |  |  |
|