Legend Of A Fighter: Viewer Comments

Viewer Comments Viewer Comments:
Legend Of A Fighter
All Content Used With Permission.


TIP: Log In to enable enhanced Interact features.NEED HELP?

    by TheChosenOne
    facebook.com/richard.trondsen


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by 1MAFRK166


Excellent.
AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YUMMMM, YEAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!I love you rater haters
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Rubberlegs


Starts off slowly, with a lot of comedy bits at the start, but once Fok Yun Gap is grown up all that is thrown out. Very tight fights scenes that really show the talent from the entire cast. I found the best scene to be when Fok Yun Gap fights the eagle claw master, great stuff. Everyone is at the top of their game in this, as is also Yuen Wo Ping for directing.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by DO63004


A good story, and yes I can see where "Fearless" was a new adaptation of this film. Not real ferocious fight sequences, but the point is made! I definitely like the fact that it features the Japanese shinobi from "Heroes of the East" as the unassuming master and subsequent would-be adversary. Good lesson on loyalty and pride. I think it's worthy of being in a collection. I'm glad I got it and think you will be too.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by PM22084


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by DeathShrike


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by MF19790


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by ER15701


I thought this was an okay movie.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by WH51750


This movie was and still is great, even for this time period. The acting was good and the action even better. All kung fu fans should have this in their archives.
AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YJV47842
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by kung fu kid


This is a great kung fu flick starring Leung Kar Yan as the legendary Fok Yun Gap, and he plays the part well. The film is directed by Yuen Wo Ping, and it shows. The action in the film is excellent and there's plenty of it too. I also think Phillip Ko Fei played a great part as the father of Leung Kar Yan's character, and Yasuaki Kurata was also great in the film. The end fight between Keung Kar Yan and Yasuaki Kurata is just awsome, as are all the fights in the movie. I thought the story was really good, and not once was I bored with it. I highly recommend this great fu movie.
AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YGreat action and great story! I agree with you this is an excellent old school classic!Sgt. T
Yone of top 25 all time old schoolJH7439
YFubar, ha, ha. Awesome reference. I haven't seen "Tango & Cash" in a while but I do dig that flick. It seems that KungfuManiac might be coming around. We should maybe give him a chance to speak his piece...Bastard Ronin
Yone of my favorites-you have good tastes my friend!!Little Dragon Fan
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Strategy786


This is a good story with excellent kung fu. Beardy shines as the lead.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by DCMAGNUM


Excellent martial arts movie. I can't remember the movie that I saw that was similar to this film, but it had a great story and excellent fighting sequences. This is a must-see.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by LG43358


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by I love you rater haters


DID I JUST REALLY WATCH THIS MOVIE!!!????

This is truly one of the best movies I have ever seen in my life, and that is no exaggeration!

Reasons why you should buy this film:

  1. The Yuen family: Yuen Woo Ping, Yuen Chiang Ren, Yuen Jen Chiang, Yuen Er Chia. (Actually that should be reason enough.)

  2. Watching Leung Kar Yan's Wing Chun style displayed on this film. In my opinion, it was better here then on "Warriors Two".
This movie is truly a gem, not because it was a great kung fu film, but because of the legend of Fok Yan Gap; Philip Ko, the Yuen family and Leung Kar Yan put their hearts in this film to let us know that. Also, if you raters gave this movie less than five stars it is sort of disrespectful knowing the work put in this film.
AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YI agree with you totally, this film is a must have for any collector!Sgt. T
Yfinally you go something right! good job man, this movie is great. Good you didn't give it 4 and half because it's the same as 5. Good job man.Rambo part 5 please
YTotally agree! Awesome training sequences!Little Dragon Fan
YI agree, this is a very enjoyable movie. My favorite role in it was Kurata sporting the glasses and pretending to be effete. Good stuff!Mad Monkey
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Sgt. T


Ng See Yuen put together a great cast and a great director to tell a different version of the legend of Hu Yuanjia/Fok Yuen Gap. Leug Kar Yan is excellent in the lead role and the under rated Yusuaki Kurata was just plain great! Remember now this is an old school film that predates Jet Li's more popular Fearless. Do not expect up dated special effects assisted martial arts action. If you love old school martial arts this film will certainly entertain you! A must have for lovers of old school movies.
AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YWell said! I'm with you on this one. One of my favorites!Little Dragon Fan
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Kung Fu Classic Viewer


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by JT35135


Great stuff with Beardy (sans beard in this movie) and Yasuaki Kurata. Kurata has to be one of the most underrated performers in HK cinema and this movie is no exception. Great tale about friendship, nationalism, and family traditions tied up with excerpts of fantastic fighting. Based on the legendary Fok Yuen Gap, as most know.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by OW2936


One of Yuen Wo Ping's best movies. Great cast and awesome fight scenes.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by SA41862


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by BA38898


This is like the Jet Li movie "Fearless". The fights were good, but lack of story made it decent. It's only good for a rent.
AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
NHahahaha, I think you have the Jet Li thing backwards. Now if you will excuse me, I have to go listen to Motley Crue's Helter Skelter; I think the Beatles remade it at some point. MS10197
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Lewis
    sawtoothlodge.org/MovieShelf.jpg


Highly recommended. It was not what I expecting for a Fok Yun Gap (Huo Yuan Chia) movie. That's the trouble with only knowing history through movies. This isn't Bruce Lee or Jet Li's (or even Donnie Yen) Legend. This is Leung Kar Yan and Yuen Wo Ping's movie and it is excellent all around.
AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YTotally agree! Leung Kar Yan and the underated Yusuaki Kurate make this a great old school feature.Sgt. T
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by JAY LEE




This is one of my favourite Leung Kar Yan movies. And I don't think "Beardy" ever looked better than when he was directed by Sammo or (in this case) Yuen Wo Ping. He really get's to show his stuff in this one.

In the beginning of the movie, the younger incarnation of the legendary character Fok Yun Gap (Huo Yun Jia) is played with youthful energy by Yuen Yat Chor. And the tone is light and comedic.

The character grows up, and Leung Kar Yan takes over. His portrayal of the righteous legend is both moving and powerful. He truly shines in the dramatic scenes, as well as the fight scenes.

Philip Ko Fei and Yasuaki Kurata both have some exellent and interesting roles as the stern father and the mysterious master. And with tight choreography by the Yuen clan, they come off better than ever in the training and fight scenes.

The Chinese vs. Japanese concept was hardly new at the time. But Ng See Yuen and Yuen Wo Ping managed to give it a fresh and interesting spin here.

The only flaw that I can think of are some brief comedic moments that are not really in keeping with the tone of the movie. But it's more of a minor annoyance than a flaw--and is easily overlooked, considering the overall quality of the piece.

I wholeheartedly recommend this to all kung fu film fans. Fearless? What? Who? This flick is where it's at, people!

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by William Giordanella


This is a very good movie. I think Jet Li's "Fearless" is just a little better, but this movie is still worth owning. Highly Recommended.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by BF40456


One of the best martial arts movies I've seen...
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by HP32586


This is an older version of the movie "Fearless" from another angle. To me this movie is great, as Huo Yen Jia has no choice but must fight his former kung fu teacher.

I was really moved when I watch this movie 30 years ago, and that is why I bought this movie once I discovered its English title. The only thing I don't like is the English dubbing.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by DT38236


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by MVR1950


Great old school Yuen Wo Ping classic. Story is great, too. In my opinion, it was much better than his remake, "Fearless", with Jet Li; because little or no wire-fu was used and absolutely no CGI back in the day.
AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YI totally agree. This is much better than Fearless. The Yuen's reliance on wire-work makes their later movies total crap.MS10197
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by KH256


"Legend Of A Fighter" was a very well done film. I would like to see an up to date version. There are a lot of old movies that could be done over today. I even wrote one of my own. but it was just something I did for fun.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by GR36629


LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by JK7434




Loved it upside down and called it back the next day, "Legend Of A Fighter" is a MUST for fans of 70's-early 80's HK films. The character is treated with respect for the folklore but Yuen doesn't hesitate to overlay him into his usual array of breakneck fight scenes, martial exploration and bizarre Cantonese comedy. Usually YWP is hit or miss with the comedy, but it's all hits here.

I have never heard in this era of film the response Phillip Ko Fei gives a troublesome intruder :). I would never expect to see Fung Hak On to do...ah, I hate spoilers, watch for yourself.

Other tidbits - I seriously doubt ol' Beardie's "Not trained in real life" story. He has yet to convince me he knows nothing. It's like Michael Jordan saying he's sick then dropping 37 on the Jazz. And the odd symmetry of Yasuaki Kurata playing a teacher to Fok, then playing a teacher to his student in "Fist of Legend" was appreciated.

Lots of quality fights, comedy and good drama, ya can't miss. Also, there's no scene of his angel being re-united with some girl he hooked up with INSTEAD OF HIS WIFE AND CHILD. (I know, not fair to compare, but that bugged me)

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by EC1872




Having recently seen Jet Li's Fearless, I was intrigued to learn of this older version of the story, and I like the fight choreography of Yuen Woo Ping's older films, where real martial artists can show off their stuff, instead of actors who rely almost entirely on wire work and camera tricks.

I found this 1980s adaptation to be quite good, although from the preview that showed presumably the original version with Mandarin dialogue and English subtitles, apparently this DVD version has been edited, as there's a scene where Huo battles a Western fencer that didn't appear in the 90 minute running time.

Also, the English dubbing transliterates the characters' names into their Cantonese versions, so the "Huo Yuan Chia" is addressed in this movie as something like "Fook Yuen Giap." For simplicity, I will follow the convention of the DVD synopsis on the back and continue referring to him as "Huo Yuan Chia."

Anyway, the training scenes are really good, especially the ones involving Yasuki Kurata, who plays Chiang Ho Shan, a Japanese karate expert to travels to China in a guise of a scholar to teach young Huo literary arts.

Ho Shan's real purpose is to secretly learn the Huo family fist style. Master Huo (played by Philip Ko Fei) has the ability to use chi energy to crush an egg inside a glass without breaking the glass itself. Master Huo also thinks his youngest son Yuan Chia is a weakling, and refuses to teach him kung-fu.

Ho Shan, who pities the boy, therefore secretly teaches him martial arts, and leaves him a training manual before returning to Japan after killing to two ruffians who try to harm Yuan Chia.

It turns out Ho Shan wants to learn the family skills mainly out of a desire to integrate many different styles, and encourages Yuan Chia to do the same. To go beyond clan and family restrictions, to spread the arts far and wide and learn from others...that seems to be message of the movie, and it's a good one.

Anyway, back to the story, master and student reunite many years later after Yuan Chia defeats an arrogant Japanese fighter, and Ho Shan is ordered by the Japanese martial arts society to challenge Yuan Chia to the death and avenge national honor.

Ho Shan is reluctant to have this fight, but he obeys and returns to China. When he finally meets his former student in the fighting gym, he deliberately does everything he can to enrage an equally reluctant Yuan Chia, who ultimately defeats his master. It is a tragic ending, however it is also apparent that Ho Shan is a great admirer of Chinese culture and still has a sense of fatherly love for Yuan Chia, and knowing that Chinese are bullied as weaklings (the time period is shortly after the Boxer Rebellion), seems to willing sacrifice himself to die at Yuan Chia's hands. After all, despite knowing the Huo family style he doesn't attempt to use it against Yuan Chia.

The movie ends with Huo Yuan Chia walking out the door to cheering Chinese crowds, and though he is saddened by his master's death, he vows to spread martial arts to the masses and develop national pride and sportsmanship.

AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YI agree with your statement concerning the choreography. The wire-work crap the Yuen's do now shouldn't even be called kung fu; it is pure garbage.MS10197
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Little Dragon Fan


Classic! Don't hesitate to buy this one! Great martial technique.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by mike lee


a totaly waste of my hard earned money. very slow fights, dumb story.worst movie ever. if you want a good kung fu movie, than go for fearless, for the same mony, you get a 10 time better film!
AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
N"Fearless" IS better, but this is a much finer film than you say.Jeffrey Frawley
Nthis was far more realistic fights than in fearless, agree with ms10197Muhtar
NAnother classic mike lee review. This movie is far superior to Fearless in every way.MS10197
NHave to agree with Sgt. T. on this one. You have to look at the film technology when the film was made. Old school kung fu stars had to really know their stuff, sfx was not as advanced.Little Dragon Fan
NFearless is a newer film, of course it would be better action wise. This film was pretty good for the time it was made, you should be more tolerant on old school films or don't watch them.Sgt. T
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by RW26943


A story of emotion and legend, this is one of Yuen Wo Ping's greatest gems; before Jet Li's "Fearless" came this marvel of martial artistry and a harsh struggle of life, racism...

It's deep. A true masterpiece.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by Buff


This is one movie that captures the essence of Kung Fu. From the student teacher relationship, and the soft and hard of kung fu and karate. Can't imagine anyone not having this in their collection. Well-paced with plenty of good fight scenes!! A true classic!!!!
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by //8144


Nice little kung-fu film starring Beardy--some above average fights, and a heart-breaking ending makes this a must-see!
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by 100pr00f
    Wutang-corp.com


Wow. This movie is nice... It's a definite must-have... Try it out, you need to see this.
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by The Dragon




"Legend Of A Fighter" is an old school martial arts film from the late 70's that gets better every time I view it. The story of the relationship between Huo and his instructor is the kind of "depth" so many films of this era were lacking. Kurata reflects a real since of mystery, spying on the Huo family's art and, winning their trust at the same time, providing the viewer sincere emotion at the films climax. The fight choreography by the Yuen clan is some of the best of that era as well. One would never have guessed that the film's lead, Leung Kar Yan, knows no Martial Arts at all, given his superb altheleticsm, and convincing dramatic performance. He reminds me of Bruce Lee in that he has the charisma to convey physical emotion to the audience. I'm truly surprised he never gained the reconition with his electrifying energy. Films such as, "Thundering Mantis", "Sleeping Fist", and "The Victim", all support my feelings on this matter. Knowing the fickle Hong Kong audiences though, it isn't surprising a talent like he got lost in the shuffle. I feel he's right up there with the respected, Ti Lung. "Legend" does suffer from a hurried pace seemingly to get the master into as many mix ups to display his art as possible, however, being the date in which this project was made, it's all worth it once the action starts! There hasn't been one of my guests I've shared this film with, that hasn't said "I like that, man! " "Legend of a Fighter" is a Martial Art film that I highly recommend to the avid kung fu film fan, or any admirer of the great Yuen Woo Ping's early action direction. Enjoy this film, again and again as I, and many others, have.
AGREE?READER COMMENTSAUTHOR
YTotally agree but I would give it 5 starsMuhtar
LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



    by John Firth


I love this film. Leung Kar Yan and Yuen Yat Choh are both good as Fok Yun Gap (older and younger respectively), whilst Yasuaki Kurata is brilliant as Chiang Ho San.

The final battle is stunning, showing both men's screen-fighting class.

LOG IN TO COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW!



CLOSE THIS WINDOW

This window is a "pop-up" from at HKFlix.com.
If you've arrived here from somewhere else,
please CLICK HERE for our home page!