| Dark, brooding, and stylish -- three words that fit this tale of underground boxing and estranged brotherhood. It does not fully connect with every punch, but director Patrick Leung comes close. One imperfection is the selection of the stars. As noted below, the supporting turns are better than the leads. So it's a bit distracting to follow the less-interesting characters. Another imperfection is the script; the writers apparently do not understand fully how fraternal twins act. Although the synopsis on the DVD itself claims the two brothers have different personalities, that's not how it's written or performed. For example, more emphasis on how Tide's life had been affected by the estrangement with his brother would have been welcome. And some plot threads are mysteriously left hanging.
Still, the strengths of Patrick Leung shine through: brief montages build mood, the shifting between present and past is handled skillfully through the use of flashbacks and intercutting, slow motion and unique camera placements are judiciously utilized. The script, though flawed, does make it clear that Tide's relationships with Sandy and Mann are different than their respective relationships with Tan Ho. The shadowy settings lean heavily on burnished colors that are beautifully captured by director of photography Joe Chan. Ringo Fun served as art director; Richard Hung choreographed the action scenes; and Chan Ki Hop did the editing. Chiu Tsang Hei and Anthony Chue composed the entrancing musical score, which leans heavily on guitars, synthesizers, and the occasional techno-beat.
Louis Koo Tin-Lok looks the part of the brooding Tan Ho, but he fails to embody the character with any real sense of danger or edge. Daniel Wu is marginally better as the quieter Tide. The problem is that neither one is able to stand up to the extremely stylish backgrounds. What's needed are actors with more physicality, strength, and personality -- someone like Patrick Tam Yiu-Man. He captures the wild and exciting side of Mann on his way up with Tan Ho, but also nails a desperate uncertainty in his scenes with Tide. Nearly as good is Jo Kuk Tso-Lam as Sandy. Felix Lok Wrath White and Park Ju Chun play the two chief opponents of Tan Ho. Also featured are Bai Ying, Chang Kuo Chu, Phyllis Quek, and Arthur Wong. |