Agreement:90% of 167 voters agree with JV47842's reviews Gender: Male Age: 26 Location: United States
Bio: I am 25 yr old man & I love films, I love every genre. My favorite genres are martial arts flicks, action, & film noirs. My background is filipino & I also trained in filipino martial arts which I recieved a black belt. I recently retired from the military. Now, working for a film magazine. I love Bruce Lee, Gordon Liu, Donnie Yen, Jackie Chan, Jet Li, Yuen Biao, Sammo Hung, Yuen Wo Ping, Cynthia Khan, Michelle Yeoh, Lo leigh, Wang Yu, Jacky Wu, & Stephen Chow films.
The One-Armed Swordsman Trilogy [3-Movie Box] (product link) Martial Arts / Action/Adventure I would highly recommend the One-Armed Swordsman trilogy to anyone who likes Shaw Brothers flicks. I watched these three classics back to back and not once was I bored. I thought the acting from Jimmy Wang Yu and Lisa Chiao Chiao in the first two movies was excellent; and also the action was really good, with loads of great bloody fight scenes. The third movie, "New One Armed Swordsman", is equally as good as its two predecessors, starring David Chiang as the one-armed swordsman and Ti Lung as his good pal. Both give great performances. I also think Ku Feng played a great part as the villain. Like the first two movies, the acting is good, with loads of great swordplay. I think Chang Cheh made three cracking movies here, and I couldn't fault them in any way. Highly recommended.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
Some of Jimmys best work and all three of these movies are a must have in your collection.
I'm not a big fan of Jimmy Wang Yu, but he is extremely good in the first two films. I am basically antagonistic toward David Chiang, but he's pretty good in the third. The central concept was obviously one that engaged Chang Cheh fully.
The Machine Girl (product link) Action/Adventure / Girls With Guns WOW, what a film. I don't think I have seen so much gore in a film like this one before. There are some crazy weapons in this movie, such as the flying guillotine 'chainsaw' and--who could forget?--the drill bra. If you like to see plenty of limbs get the chop and loads of blood squirting everywhere, then you've come to the right place. This is the beautiful Minase Yoshiro's debut film and she doesn't disappoint either. This is sure to entertain.
The film is over-hyped by many reviewers. I did say "Chocolate has good action scenes" It's for the action person. A good kung fu film has a good story 2 follow, so that were not trying to dumb down asian cinema. U need to watch more real fu films.
3 Iron (product link) Drama / Crime This is one of the best modern love stories I have seen in awhile. The movie is unique and the two main characters are utterly brilliant in their silent roles. I absolutely adore this picture and the filmmaking is magnificant. This is a must-have for anyone that wants an original love story or a picture that would make you think about your own personal life.
This is one of the only Japanese movies made that can compete with "Casshern" for the title of "Worst Japanese Film Ever". With its horrible acting, disjointed plot, and an inexplicable and infantile anti-Americanism, it's hard to pinpoint which of these contributes the most to this film's utter awfulness. These shortcomings could be somewhat overlooked if the film were exciting, but, alas, it is so boring, it will make you want to step outside to watch the grass grow.
For me personally, the most irksome part of the whole film (I use the term loosely when describing this piece of shit) was its ridiculous anti-Americanism; evidently justifying 9-11 was supposed to imbue this "provocative" film with a measure of anti-establishment street cred. The message this dreadful movie seemingly wishes to convey is that terrorists, including the "heroes" of the story, are really only misunderstood idealists rather than cold-blooded mass-murderers.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
The idiocy of this film not to mention the sloppy storytelling, atrocious acting, and utter lack of character development left me dumbfounded. A total stink bomb.
While this is less than a shadow of the first film, within its own universe the teenagers' terrorism is not an evil thing, as their deaths had previously been decreed by society simply for being alive: they are no worse than partisans or chetniks.
Bang on about this film, it really is truly dreadful, I must admit though I always felt that the original was incredibly overrated, as apart from the initial sequence it is stomach-churningly soppy! Worst Japanese Movie ever? Absolutely.
Once Upon A Time In America (product link) Crime / Drama Sergio Leone made at least three masterpieces: "The Good, The Bad And The Ugly", "Once Upon A Time In The West", and this. This is better than the others--more psychologically deep, more excellently scored, and much, much better acted. In its initial U.S. release, this great film was absolutely castrated: restructured into a much shorter chronological sequence rather than moving back and forth in time, and leaving out the introductions, youth, adulthood, and deaths of important characters.
This is not a film to approach literally: it is Noodles Aaronson's (Robert De Niro's character) story told as he knows it, remembers it, or thinks it was. I can't say what "really" happened. Neither can Noodles. Do not step away from the picture or turn it off before the final image: it is important. I think I may know what really happened, but maybe not.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
N
Love the childhood part. Like the 1933 part. Hate the 1968 part. To etheral and artsy for its own good. It pains me to say this, but Leone dropped the ball on this one!
No & yes. The film does have it's unforgettable moments but due to the fact I felt a little short handed by the ending. I felt it ended when they crashed the car.
And do not forget to mention Leone's " Duck, You Sucker" which is originally apart of his "American trilogy". I agree with your review. This is one of those films that will stay with the viewer forever.
Shinobi (product link) Action/Adventure / Fantasy This has got to be the worst ninja movie ever. I don't understand why people rated it so high. Sure, I watched the manga and anime version, it's great, but the live action version sucks because they don't have the budget to make the special effects look real, and the actors look so fake. I can't believe how dumb this movie is. As I said, if you have no brain and still believe in fantasy and fairy tales, then this movie suits you perfectly. But if you are a hardcore kung fu action fan like me, stay away from it at all costs. I think that's why we're here in the first place!
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
N
I neither agree/disagree with your review but you watched a Japanese "ninja" movie for hardcore kung fu action? Lolz
In fact NO WAY, if you have no brain then you wouldn't notice the great storyline that this movie offers. Man, this movie has everything. Each to their own. But shit, you missed a magic movie here.
I'm not sure if I would call this a ninja movie and I could see where some hardcore kung fu fans could dislike it, but I felt this was well done and quite interesting. I couldn't help feel like I was watching a superior version of the X-Men
Bow down and show some respect for one of the top ten all time greatest kung fu flicks. Lower. Let me start of by saying that I just really wanted to write a review for this movie but I acknowledge that Jay Lee probably wrote the best review for this movie already. Just giving props to those that are deserving. Now to my insane ramblings of blather that are often misinterpreted and in some cases incomprehensible due to my heavy use of logic and honesty.
This one doubles as not only my favorite Gordon Liu movie but also as my favorite Shaw Brothers movie. I know there are so many to choose from and you think that one is the best and dude over there is all like "what about the '36th Chamber'?" Well, chill, we're talking about my favorites now, not yours. We talk about your favorites in your review, sucka.
Lau Kar Leung crafts this movie and its fight scenes with inspired perfection. Gordon Liu dishes out the goods with the jack-of-all trades fu by demonstrating that old school multiple proficiency that pretty much died in the 90's when everyone could just have a single gimmick and still get by. This movie is not only arguably Gordon Liu's best martial arts performance but also Yasuaki Kurata's as well. You have to wait all the way to the end to see Yasuaki finally get down; but when he does, HOLY SHIT, he's a fuckin' smokin' now! (Maybe, just maybe, there is one "Family Guy" fan out there who got that reference. Probably not.)
Anyhow, this film has got one of the best complilations of variety in martial arts styles and weapons put to use. The Japanese performers and characters are all straight-up bad-asses, and really Japanese, unlike many other Chinese films that used Chinese actors and portrayed the Japanese as bitch-made predatory miscreants. I'm not judging, I'm just sayin'. Well, I guess to truly complete a review for this movie I got to give up my favorite fight. Damn, there are so many to choose from, but if I had to pick one favorite I would cheat and say the entire end fight with Gordon and Yasuaki, which is basically like 3-4 fights in one. I don't mean to beat a dying horse (unless it's called for or I'm bored or something), but Mr. Kurata is so frickin' slick it's unreal. The man handles a ninja-to like he was born holding one, and his crab style is one of the dopest, slickest and most creative things I have ever seen. This movie has everything for martial arts lovers including a tough chick.
I also got to say Buddha bless Dragon Dynasty for releasing these perfectly digitally remastered fu classics with the original subtitles and dubbings while including all kinds of sweet bonuses like interviews with the legends that made these movies possible. Make sure this is in your collection. Essential and severely enjoyable.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
the ratings and the reviews say it all. a must have for any collector
If HKFLIX had higher star rating, this movie would be up there. The movie is amazing, it had no blood, & no finishing movies but it entertains. Plus it's a great history lesson too.
"Crime Story" was based on a true story of the kidnapping of Teddy Wang, a Hong Kong multi-billionaire. The film is considered to be fairly accurate, although director Kirk Wong had to make some changes and the police would not release a lot of information on the case. Wong still tried to portray the events as accurately as he could--for example, the location of the kidnapping in the film was very close to the real event. It has also been said that the original ending of the billionaire drowning was likely his real fate, but was changed to a happy ending at the request of his widow, Nina Wang, who owned the cineplexes.
"Crime Story" was also Chan's first film based on a true story and one of his first major dramatic roles. The action was also pretty good as Chan took more of a streetfighting approach and showed no sign of his normal lighthearted sense of humor which is probably why some fans do not like this film. There was a lot of intensity in the fighting and Chan and his stunt team took many nasty falls. The explosions and fires were also well done as the old Kowloon walled city was burned and leveled.
The acting throughout the film was very good as Jackie Chan more than proved he can pull off this type of role. Kent Chang was great as always as police inspector/kidnapper Hung. It was also amazing how actor Law Kar Ying and actress Au-Yeung Pooi San looked like the real Teddy and Nina Wang.
I think this is a good film that allowed Jackie Chan to take on a new and challenging role that could be used as an example to critics who think Chan cannot act or take dramatic roles as he progresses in age.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
Superb quality work from Jackie and Kent Cheung! Ashley the world is not black or white. As you go through life you will find a lot of gray. There are times when "the truth" will only kill more people. What little was left out did not change the story.
Jackie Chan and Kent Chang were excellent in this police drama. I agree with you on Chan silencing his critics for this particular dramatic role. Jackie was also good in " The New Police Story"!
The movie was such a disappointment because in order to tell a true story the audience needs a true story of what actually happened. The action in the film was good but the truth of the story should have been told.
This was one of the few remaining Jackie Chan films I hadn't yet seen, and after seeing an explosive and exciting trailer for it, I was foaming at the mouth wondering why I hadn't yet. Now that I've seen it, I kinda wish I hadn't.
The trailer promised action--more action than I could shake a chopstick at. This film didn't have any though. It was a long, boring police drama based on a true story (supposedly) of a high profile kidnapping in which Chan plays a relentless cop. It's dialog heavy and the acting is terrible.
On one hand, as a Jackie Chan film, it's easily among his worst, and I can't understand why people like it so much. I've come to expect over-the-top action, stunts and fighting with amazing set pieces from his films. This was a bit of a departure from his other films at the time as he played a darker and more serious realistic character. That doesn't mean it's good. He's played a darker character in other films where it totally works. Here it's just a waste of talent.
As a police drama, it fails as well because the story is cliched and dull. It's also mostly a failure as an action film--until the end, that is, where it earns that extra half a star.
I recommend watching this like a porn: just fast forward through all the talking and watch the action. Basically, skip the first 4/5ths of this movie until you get to the end--and even then, it's barely worth your time. The action and set-pieces scattered throughout were weak for the most part and nothing you haven't seen. It's not until the very end that we finally get to see some classic JC--it's pretty clear which scenes he directed.
Even when things were exploding everywhere and the story had reached its ultimate climax, I was catching myself drifting off and just thinking about how Jackie Chan's hair kept changing length throughout the film, as though they had to do a bunch of reshoots or else they shot it out of sequence. That's probably why it felt so uneven.
Ultimately I'd say skip it, but most people out there seem to think this is some quality genius work. I'm a Jackie Chan enthusiast, but his comedic energy isn't what was missing here--what was missing was a good movie. There's literally nothing worth seeing that they don't show in the trailer. I'd suggest picking up "New Police Story" for a better example of a darker side of Chan, or "Thunderbolt" for some of the most fantastic stunts in a Chan film ever (just try to ignore the actual car racing scenes) instead.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
N
Excellent film, plot and acting. Just because something is different does not necessarily make it bad. I think you skipped way too much!
Vengeance Is Mine [1979] (product link) Drama / Thriller Ken Ogata is stunning in the role of a Japanese serial killer whose rampage is long beyond his or the authorities' control. In the end, there is a partial explanation of his mania. There are many people like him.
A low level gangster (Wong) kills his boss (Shing Fui On) and his wife after he is caught sleeping with her, causing him to flee to South Africa where he works in a Chinese restuarant. His new boss (Lo Meng) hired him to work cheap and his wife always bullies him, prompting him to kill them too and return to Hong Kong with the dreaded Ebola Virus he received after raping a Zulu woman. It turns out he is one of a small percentage that is immune and is able to carry and spread the disease. Wong takes it upon himself to return and spread the virus in response to a lifetime of being bullied.
This film is another collaboration between director Herman Yau and Anthony Wong as they clearly tried to push the envelope even farther than the cult classic, "Untold Story". This is a very sleazy and dark film, with Anthony Wong rising to his repulsive peak. Like "Untold Story", Wong perfectly portrays a vile human being that alone makes the film worthwhile for viewers with a strong stomach.
Also included are several comedic quotes from sleazeball Wong that add lighter moments before and after the mayhem. Some of these lines are very amusing but probably not suitable to repeat. Director Herman Yau is an expert at setting the mood for these kind of films with many intense and repulsive moments. One great scene was when a mouse was run over by the cab Wong was riding in, showing that death follows this man no matter what type of breathing creature or the circumstances. Not even children were spared in this one.
Despite its many disgusting moments, "Ebola Syndrome" is a well made film with another great preformance from Anthony Wong in a role he seems all too comfortable in. This may also be the most unsanitary film ever made as blood, sweat, semen, and saliva were flying all over the place throughout the 98-minute runtime. I like that Herman Yau brought back the human beef buns from "Untold Story" (Africa Buns in this film) and also added a nifty spit cam that gives the audience an extra disgusting close up view. The moral of the story, if it has one, is to watch who you bully.
The Warriors (product link) Crime / Action/Adventure Warriors come out and plaaaaaayyy. Hell, yeah, fools, act like you know.
The essential classic gang movie. This was 1979, long before gangster rap and Jerry Springer convinced kids it was cool to bring automatic weapons to school and shoot shit up. Back then it was about the throw down. Chains, bats, knives and fists and wits were all real tough, juvenile, outlaw, bastards needed. These kids lived by a code. This adventure was as much about brotherhood as it was about survival.
One of the ultimates in sheer entertainment and adrenaline supplements. One of my all time top 20 movies. If you are not hip, get hip, 'cause "The streets are ours, suckas. It's all ours. Can you dig it?"
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
Its supposed to be silly thats part of its charm. There is no indication that this film was trying to be serious so just sit and enjoy the sillyness
MS10197 is probably right that this should be taken as a comedy - or something or another else than a realistic thriller, anyway - but I am convinced that it works quite well as whatever it is. "Wah-ree-urz, come out to play-ayyy!"
I think this movie is best taken as a comedy, as silly as it is. Gangs dressed as baseball clowns with a sultry radio host announcing their every move? Come on. This is just plain silly
This is a 5 star awesomely entertaining Walter Hill flick-it's a late 70's80's pic but it's timeless & the directors cut was well done a lot better then the original, I loved the comic strips that detailed the story! i agree with ur review.
Hold onto your hats, sports fans, and try and keep your knickers dry. We have an excellent treat here for all you film lovers. This is one of those movies that can either make or break your Asian film collection. If you don't own it, stop reading right now and purchase the shit. I'll be here when you get back. Now, for the rest of you folks that still aren't sure, "Battle Royale" is monumental entertainment. It combines a deeply probing psychological survey on the effects of extraordinary stress and survival/primal extincts that manifest under extreme (and shady) circumstances in the under-developed minds of children--as well as the media-frenzied constantly escalating bloodlust. Don't be mistaken, folks, this is a story that could one day take place in our world and possibly during our lifetimes. "Battle Royale" draws from many themes of film, books, and short stories that came before it, but it molds these themes into something that winds up feeling truly original. Raw, graphic violence is mixed with stirring emotion and remarkable performances for maximum effect. While I have not read the book, I have every intention of doing so because this story holds the boldness and potency of the classics of literature such as "I Am Legend" (survival against odds),"1984" (society's dystopian circumstances) or even the "Hagakure" ("The Way of the Samurai is in desperateness...Simply become insane and desperate."-page 45 1983 ed. paperback). The film is powerful on so many levels. I did read the entire 15 volume manga though and that rocks, so you should probably go get that too. Now, understand that you will cringe a few times during your first viewing because the action is so raw and the kids are young; so this may provide slight sensory overload, but you'll get over it. You're a big kid now. This movie was everything that "A Clockwork Orange" tried to be. I personally think that Stanley Kubric failed to capture the emotional content of the book I keep hearing about (never read that book either). While one of my dudes on this site does hold that film in high regard I can't help but feel that it came off as meaningless whereas this film ("Battle Royale") comes off as profound and powerful.
If you don't have it, I would give it my highest recommendation; and if you do have it, you should probably watch it at least once every year to keep good company with a well crafted story. Thanks for the time, campers, I got to peel.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
Good review. I can understand that someone wouldn't like this film for its controversial nature and content, but saying it is hyped up and not a well made film is ridiculous
Everyone should see this movie, as a test: Those who like it should be heeded; We need not listen to those who do not. It's great (so...you should heed me...really).
Great review. You definitely nailed some of the better points. I'm still trying to work-up what I want to say in my review. You handled it well. 5 stars, hands down.
Battle Royale is a hyped up movie and it's really not that great, kids killing other kids on a remote island- I guess somebody ripped off Lord of the Flies.
def. agree this is an awesome flick about kids goin wild! And agree with your point on a clockwork orange & kubrick- the novel had a much better narrative than the film. The message of the film is powerful- I love this film.
Took me awhile to finally check out this flick. It was completely worth it.
"Cloverfield" is packed with high energy thrills and unyielding momentum. The story told is very simplistic, but that may add to the classic qualities of this feature. This is the best monster movie that I have seen in years. It even trumps "The Host", which is no small feat. You got a little something for everybody: action, excitement, drama, and humor. I know the whole shaky-cam thing did bother a lot of folks, but honestly I thought it was a very good device for the whole movie as it added to the frantic nature of the film while grounding it in a gritty and realistic manor that almost seems to give the monster that much more credibility.
FINAL SUMMATION: This flick is more fun than you can have with a German shepherd, a hooker, and a whole jar of peanut butter. Go check this one out. Highly entertaining, you won't be let down. Now, I got to bolt. I have to fly a 747 to England in 20 minutes and this whiskey isn't going to drink itself.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
4 1/2 stars is a stretch but this is a clever and entertaining film that is worth more than just an assortment of special effects like some other movies
When Cloverfield came out, everybody was so hyped out about it. I saw the picture and it's not that great. I admitt it's a better version of Godzilla US version. This movie is just plain stupid & really bad.
Zatoichi [2003] (product link) Drama / Swordplay/Sword(s) Absolute masterpiece. Beat Takeshi weaves a wonderful satirical tale in a world full of memorable characters all the way down to the workmen who keep time with the soundtrack. Even if you aren't a fan of samurai films or have any real knowledge of the Zatoichi film series, you will love this movie.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
Choco is correct: This is very much a Takeshi Kitano film, as virtually anything in which he appears is. This is a respectful but still individualistic tribute to Shintaro Katsu's Zatoichi series.
The Way Of The Dragon (product link) Martial Arts total dis agree, the fight were slow, story is boring, i don't see any special about this film, why people say bruce lee is so great? has he win any world boxing match? no, has he defeat any champion? no, so he just an average human being, his movie is nothing special, just some basci kick and punch, i feel like i can do better!
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
N
mike you are an ignorante- read the books so you can understand what he accomplished and then read the books written about you.
Again Mike, this film is a product of the seventies. Bruce Lee directed, and did the fight choreography. Besides the great Chuck Norris fight, Bruce turns in an awsome comic performance!
Damn, was it something I said? Seriously, though, I would like to thank all of you for all the comments that you have been posting. It's cool to see that some of you are enjoying my rants and diatribes. I really appreciate all of the honest feedback and insights as a writer, a reviewer and as an Asian cinema fan. You folks have been really great and helpful in my ongoing growth as a writer, so again thank you all. Now, let's talk about a movie.
"China Strike Force" is an oddball throwback to the glory days of Hong Kong cop actioners with a new school twist and a touch of Americanized compost. In fact the movie is in English even though that is not the native dialect of over half the cast. And it shows. The acting was, let's say, slightly less than serviceable. Oddly enough, Coolio wound up delivering his lines pretty well and was funny more intentionally than not, unlike some of his co-stars. And of course there's Mark.
Mark Dacascos is always a pleasure to watch--his acting is halfway decent and his martial arts skills are A-list quality. It's kind of a bitch that he never really blew up the way he should have. But isn't that always the way? JCVD gets famous and he bites. Pop stars and Hollywood megastars get highly funded kung fu vehicles and they are all undeserving. But what of Mark Dacascos, Ernie Reyes Jr., Scott Adkins, and Brad Allen (and many others)? Where are their big contracts for major action movies? Someone or something out there controlling the cosmic balance has the most twisted sense of humor. I mean, think about it. John Lennon: shot and killed; Martin Luther King, Jr.: shot and killed; Ronald Reagan: shot and wounded, survived. What kind of shit is that?!? People, we must protect the balance if God won't. Live your lives with some degree of honor and stay vigilant. Hopefully we can protect what is sacred.
Whoa, sorry about that folks, I'm starting to wear this soapbox out. Before I shot out into left field I think we were dicussing a movie of some kind. Right? So, "China Strike Force" is inconsistant in the acting department and plain and standard on the whole plot thing, but how is the action? Pretty good, actually. Stanley Tong always seems to craft some kinetic fights with high energy, and this movie is no exception as we are given some very functional choreography. The previously mentioned Mark Dacascos gets to shine in this arena. While he only really gets two fights and is basically gypped out of the end fight, he still gets to show off his goods with style, grace, and power. The stunts are well done, but despite the enjoyable action there are still lags here and there due in part to poor direction and choppy acting. The end fight was kind of disappointing as well. Though it had a definite element of danger, it did not have the pace or quality of the rest of the fights.
Overall I did enjoy it and I would say it is worth checking out, but it won't necessarily become one of your favorites. Thanks for the time. Stay up on the down. I got stuff to do but we'll catch up.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
Those who can appreciate a Mark Dacascos film have already admitted they can let good action outweigh terrible writing and acting. I'd rate it a bit lower than you do, but on purely action grounds it's not too bad.
I think people are a little too hard on this movie. Of course it's gonna be goofy when it stars a rapper and a pop star. The violence is worth it and I don't mind the stunt doubles either. And come on, if you like Mark Dacascos, suck it up and watch it.
Stanley Tong's 2000 movie "China Strike Force" is a messy film, the action was very weak. And the Coolio character did not belong at all even though he was the main villan. Though your reviews are great. This movie was messy.
Ghost Dog: The Way Of The Samurai (product link) Art / Drama You people need to get aware. There was only one review for this and it sucked. Pay attention, folks, damn. Anyhow, this flick has cult king written all over it. I rarely disagree with the HKFlix evalutation of a movie but they were unreasonably hard on this one. This movie is actually quite brilliant and probably tied with "Throw Down" for best adaption of the samurai code and methodolgy to a contemporary setting in films.
"Ghost Dog: The Way Of The Samurai" is evenly distributed entertainment that is filled with great performances from a diverse and talented cast, timeless quotes from the "Hagakure" (the book of the samurai), laugh-out-loud humor and good portions of gunfire. You won't be bored for one minute if you have any kind of an attention span at all. Intelligent, provocative, funny and highly entertaining I would recommend this film to anyone.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
I'd rate this slightly lower, but you are basically correct.
JJ is a director you either love or you get put to sleep. I was expecting an action flick, to my first viewing was a disappointment. Once I removed my expectations and gave it more viewings I saw what it was doing. A cameo from RZA to top it off.
This movie tried to hard to explore a character's mind set. The movie didn't not go anywhere, 4 an art picture is was just bland. The movie as a whole was not clear on wht kind of story it wanted 2 tell-therefor the actors we're distracted in their roles
The film does entertain but it's mostly for the people that are into the samurai pictures. I love samurai movies but when they modernize it, I just can't get into that stuff.
The movie was all right, I think the performances were good- I just couldn't get that much involved with it though. The movie is not for everyone, I guess I came with high expectations going in. Tht is 1 mistake tht nobody should do in a pic such as this.
Hey thnks for the comments, your right I only had one review. I thought "Ghost Dog" was an entertaing pic but it's not my taste. The film is well shot but compared to "Throwdown" that was amazing.
i just read the comment you left kungfumaniac and i'm totally with you on that one i think the reviewer in question is fubar if you dont know what that means watch tango and cash.
I agree man. This is Jim Jarmusch's vision of the samurai code, the film is entertaining. Check out Jean-Pierre Melville "Le Samouraï" it's a 1967 hitman film, the guy follows the code too. It's Johnnie To's fave film, & John Woo models his films from it.
CONTROVERSIAL REVIEW WARNING: What I got to say ain't nice. To be fair this review is for the American version of the film as I have not seen the uncut version. I would like to remind you that the exits are on both sides of the aisles. Should any danger above water present itself, the person sitting next to you can be used as a flotation device. Now just relax and enjoy the ride. Please assume crash positions.
I was cheated. I was robbed. Just about any amount of money you paid to see this movie that exceeds four U.S. dollars is a vicious ripoff. Was the fight sequence with the ladder phenomenal? Absolutely. Was that pretty much the only thing worthwhile in this flick? Absolutely. This movie brings shame to the immensely entertaining "Police Story" series by skimping on the fu and fight scenes. Of course there is an underwater fight at the end--meaning slow and lacking the type of dynamic aesthetics we have come to expect from a Jackie film. "First Strike" basically is a meandering, through-the-motions, on auto-pilot Jackie film. Perhaps I was mildly entertained at random throughout, but for the most part I just can't justify giving a movie that I only appreciated for one fight scene more than one and a half stars. Sorry but this is only for strict Jackie completists. I love Jackie just like you folks. That's why this film doesn't do it for me. He's better than that.
Do me a favor: at the next wedding you attend slap a bridesmaid on the ass during the ceremony. If you are questioned on this just tell them you got the idea from a bastard. Enjoy your movies, kids.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
Speaking only of the Dimension release, this is correct.
I'm a big JC fan but the American version is a mess, but a 2 star mess for me. Try the uncut version and you'll like this film better, the problem with Dimension film releases of JC movies is the constant cutting of scenes deemed not worthy! Shame!
I saw the American cut in theaters in the late 90's. I finally got to see the original version a few years after and it was worth it. The American Cut works though it's still fun for any Jackie Chan fan.
This Jackie Chan feature has terrific stunts & a nice fight scene thrown in the middle. The action was really impressive. Though it is cheesy, it has the Mr. Chan charm. JC antics are always impressive, he's funny & fun- the film is a blast.
"Police Story 4" has a wild set-up, the movie was good. It had nice stunts, a classic ladder fight, & the under-water fight was clever. The movie was fun, and it still manages to entertain.
Kill! (product link) Action/Adventure / Swordplay/Sword(s) Kihachi Okamoto's finest film. I absolutely love that director. He also made "Sword Of Doom".
"Kill!" is an off-beat samurai rebellion picture that refrences Kurosawa movies. The film is also funny. This is a definitely a classic movie.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
I like "Sword of Doom" even more, but this is still a legitimate 5 star film.
I completely agree. This movie is tight. Didn't mean to trip on you so hard but I've been defending "Dragon Tiger Gate" for a while and it sets me kind of sideways when someone calls it a movie for chicks. We're square though.
Seven Swords (product link) Martial Arts / Swordplay/Sword(s) How could one review a movie such as "Seven Swords", and try to be brief but still be fully expressive of the enjoyment, and satisfaction one will feel when they view a movie that shows the Western cinema world the Asian market has surpassed them. You want an epic movie of blockbuster capacity? Or maybe you're looking for a film that merges old - school with tommorrow's stars. Here one will own a movie that will forever be a favorite. One will watch this movie and save it...not for a rainy day! No...that does it no justice. Save it, to forget the beautiful martial arts, exciting plot/story and wonderful choreography, save it, to only re - live that same elating experience, where the back of your chair becomes your seat...and your seat becomes your foot rest. Save it, for a good day to only get better. Suggest...NO! I demand one to add this to their repertoire.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
Valid points, good review..maybe a half star less. Ignore those who have no knowledge of film Asian Wu xia or the world in general.
i can understand how this film got more than 2 stars. There were so many involuntary humorous moments, so much pretense, .... I think Tsui Hark should stick to producing
I am saying no because I do not know which version you are referring to. The international version is a mess, it slaps together with no ease & a lot of confusion. The original cut of the film has a better story telling & the pace is fantastic.
I know I'm probably going to get some flak for this. It seems that the overall feeling of this movie is split right down the middle. Half the fans think it is an all-time great and the other half of the fans feel like it was a pile of crap that completely cheated its audience. I'm on the fence myself. Although I do have definite feelings about this movie. The audience was cheated. This was nowhere near a great or perfect 5-star movie. Hell no. None of the actors'/martial artists' potential was fully utilized. The choreography was banal recycled rerun type of stuff, and to be honest I get sick of those repetitive "super technique" flicks (though "super style" flicks always seem to kick ass-except this one; it's both). Many champs were wasted. It did capture the feel and style of old school fu flicks but much like "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" it just recycled more than it refreshed which almost makes it feel a little less like an old school fu flick because those old schoolers were always good for showing us something random, different or new--something that we had never seen before. This flick is like too many that we have seen before.
Despite all of this, it is done fairly well and there are moments you will appreciate; but altogether it is not really worth it for true Asian cinephiles--but it might be cool for your preteen nephew as a warm up before you show him those real old school classics that will blow him away.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
Ugh, one the worst Lar Ka lau films ever concieved. I hate kung fu films that teaches "Killing those who raped your mother is not nice." GIVE ME A BREAK!
I was entertained and it was good seeing older versions of Gordon Liu, Chi Kwun Chun, and the great Lau Kar Leung,but this film did miss on quite a few things.
I probably like this more than you do, but it is very seriously flawed in the treatment of the three young fighters: What is supposed to be funny just isn't.
I agree with your review. The movie is not great and will never be consider a classic. The stars talents were def. wasted in this attempt to make something old, new again. The movie has it moments but most of the time it's another ridicoulous film.
There are a lot of reasons to love this movie. The first is because this is the type of movie that would never get made in America, at least not without some serious revisions. Second, I wish my high school was like this. Sure, it was a big sausage fest, but it certainly would be fun.
Having grown up thinking that John Hughes films were the best possible outcome for high school, and seeing the current high school experience captured as a Disney musical or stupid, forgettable, comedies, "Crows Zero" gives a new perspective on the "coolest possible" high school experience.
"Crows Zero" is about the new guy in town trying to get to the top of his high school class. But instead of getting good grades or being the quarterback with the cheerleader girlfriend, it's all about who can mobilize the best student army and pound the snot out of everyone else. But, being a Takashi Miike film ("Sukiyaki Western Django", "Ichi", "Izo", "DOA"), it's gonna' be more than a fistfight.
"Crows" is based on a multi-million selling manga. It basically takes all the conflicts and angst that you find in high school and externalizes them. Instead of stupid pranks or getting stuffed in a garbage can or trying to make the best grades or trying to get a varsity letter, it all comes down to how well you can brawl. The "School of Crows" is known for being the toughest school in Japan, and if you can survive--better yet, rise to the top--you can be whatever you want.
It's a cool premise. One that could quickly degenerate into an adolescent orgy of senseless violence or could just come off very cheesy. But Miike brings depth to the characters. Despite everyone dressing in black, they all have their own distinctive styles (and it looks cool as hell). And everyone broods really well. I mean, it's an old-school James Dean, Brando kind of brood. Nowadays our emo generation in the US tries to brood, but it's just pouting and whining. In Miike's hands it's stylistic and effective and makes you want to adopt a perma-scowl next time you leave the house.
Although the main character's run at the top is the primary story, there are a few side-stories involving peripheral characters that keep the movie from being two-dimensional and shallow. You get a sense of the kind of world where this story could take place, and the types of people that inhabit it (hint: it's a pretty cool world).
Character, story, depth, and the action is great. No showy choreography here, everything is a straight-up brawl. Think "Fight Club" turned up to 11, fueled by out-of-control teenage testosterone. Every time a fist connects with a face, you feel it. The sound and camerawork make every punch and kick feel epic. Every hit counts. And everything is captured in the very-stylistic Miike way.
So who's gonna like this movie? The anime and manga crowd should dig it. It definitely keeps its feel as a manga-made-real. Those who were into "Battle Royale" and the contemporary, Japanese, teenage, ultraviolence. I don't think this film is mature enough to appeal to the drama audience, despite having some fantastic characters and story elements. Die-hard martial arts fans should probably pass. If you like that cool Asian style with some hardcore brawling action, all done by a top-notch production team and cast, equalling a movie that oozes nonchalant cool without forgetting to be fun, you'll be a "Crows" fan, guaranteed.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
It took me forever to finally check this out but you are so right. There are a lot of reasons to love this movie. I think I'm a fan for life now.
Crows Zero is one for the pop culture. I have read the Manga series, which I love. The movie is just to forceful. It does have good direction & action but as a whole I felt a little let down.
Sukiyaki Western Django (product link) Action/Adventure / Western If you can get by the Japanese actors speaking English then you will love this film a lot. I loved it, it was a perfect thrill ride.
"The Forbidden Kingdom" is a bit of a conundrum, and it's really impossible to rate it. It's a family martial arts film with a white kid in the middle of an otherwise all-Chinese cast, directed by an American who has really just done kiddy comedies up to this point. The film has a kind of "Neverending Story" vibe, where a wimpy, bullied kid gets transported into another land to go on a fantastical adventure. So it's a bit confusing to see names like Jet Li, Jackie Chan, and Yuen Wo-Ping in the credits. But nonetheless, there they are. And despite Jet and Jackie's charismatic shenanigans, the fight scenes feel bloated and unoriginal. Yuen Wo-Ping really phoned this one in--either that or he was hired more for his name than for his actual involvement, which seems likely considering the gratuitous amount of CGI employed in many of the fight sequences.
There are lots of little nods to the kung fu flix of old that will likely appeal to genre fans, but I couldn't help wondering while I was watching the film who the intended audience really was. True genre fans would likely find this film to be childish and unengaging on the whole. Casual fans whose primary exposure to the genre has been through crossover films like "Crouching Tiger" would also likely find this film lacking in emotional depth and motivation. And kids--well, kids would probably like most of it, though a lot of the violence did seem a bit harsh for a young'un. I guess the idea was to make something for young teens whose parents might have been Shaw Brothers fans back in the day? I'm just guessing here.
The bottom line is that if you're watching this with your 13-year-old son, you'll probably come away mildly entertained and he'll come away with possibly a new favorite movie. But if there's no 13-year-old boy in your scenario, then you might want to skip this one and seek out something a bit more decisive--a movie that has actually something to say or at least an innovative way of saying it.
The only word that keeps popping into my head when I think about this movie is "cute". If "cute" is enough for you to justify a couple of hours, then more power to you. Otherwise, don't lose any sleep over missing this one.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
People are hella hatin on this one. We all know that this is not our kind of flick, but it wasn't all that bad.
Your impression of its nebulous identification of an audience is correct. When I watch Jackie Chan I want Jackie Chan-style action; When I watch Jet Li I want his expert wushu. Neither needs to be dumbed down.
I threw away any good expectation but not too bad for family fare. Not just a monkey, the Monkey King! I think a big part of this was just to satisfy the fans desire to see Jc fight Jet
I did not enjoy this film at all- Jet Li as a monkey? and Boston kids don't act like that. This being the 1st film with jackie & jet fight why did it have to be this movie? I always thought their fight should have been more realistic than fantasy.
A very interesting entry from those wacky folks with snotty accents whom we call the French (sometimes we call them worse). "B13" has high energy and excellent momentum that carries through. There are some excellent acrobatics and martial arts techniques in this film, and it's nice to see a halfway decent exhibition of Parkour (a French psuedo-martial art that is really kind of a knockoff of Peking opera performers' acrobatic tricks in kung fu flicks--i.e. Jackie, Sammo, Yuen, Yuen, Yuen, Yuen, etc. style). Very entertaining and a fun ride. Although, I have to make a side note. The film is only a four star movie the first time you see it. Each additional viewing is more like three and a half stars, as the pace is very good but if you were to evaluate it more thoroughly you will notice it is actually quite short in the fight department. Your first viewing will sort of trick you with its good pacing, fun chase scenes and hyper active filming style, but the fights that are present are quite enjoyable and worth checking out (even though I think that there might only be two of them). Get it just to give your fu collection more diversity. You got plenty of Chinese stuff, a bunch of Japanese stuff, some good Korean stuff, that cool German one, you might as well just have to make room for some more fu from the frogs. The French, I mean. I said French. I got to cut out, Interpol has found me again. Where the hell am I gonna hide all this crap?
The plot is thin and the acting barely competent, but I don't care: The parkour, fighting and general energy level make this a very fun movie to watch.
You also got a Chile fu film "Kiltro", plus I saw a Denmark fu movie called "Fighter". It's amazing how martial arts styles influence other countries. If we all knew fu, the world would be peaceful. B:14 is in pre-production get ready for more.
Everyone and their mommas got to review this flick so pretty much everything that can be said about this flick has been said already. I guess I shouldn't even bother. Wait a minute, screw that, I want a piece too.
A lot of folks seem to think that this is one of the greatest kung fu movies of all time. Those folks know what they are talking about. This ball of thunder laced lightning hits rougher and heavier than a Kimbo Slice uppercut. We all know the deal and we all know who's in it. The real eternal question is: which match-up is sicker? Jet vs. Yasuaki Kurata, or Jet vs. Billy Chow? There's a stumper for you. They both rock so hard that if you bring up this question among your friends who are into fu flicks it will usually spark a pretty wild debate. I personally lean slightly toward the Jet/Yasuaki showdown. Something about wind and blindfolds--it just gets me going, dude.
"Fist Of Legend" is possibly the closest thing to perfect fight choreography around (perfect is relative, but honestly it might be perfect) and incorporates many martial art styles, such as Longfist, Ditang Chuan, Tong Bei, Chin Na, Aikido, Karate, boxing, Judo, Jujitsu, and quite a few more that I am probably forgetting. I know some cats say that the general was using Muay Thai. They have either poor eyesight or just improper schooling. Billy's just busting out with hardcore Karate.
This movie is the dope shit and every last one of you know it. If you haven't seen it, you better head for the hills, son, because we will hunt you down and staple you to something so we can force you to see this awesome piece of kung fu cinema history. You'll probably thank us afterwords and maybe even offer us a beer. And we'll accept. 'Cause we like beer. Keep kicking for the stars, folks. I'll be around.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
didn't like it as much has some cuz I hate remakes but this is the schitzer, ACHTUNG! :)
I've seen a lot of reviews for "Fist of Legend" this week. I am pumped for the Dragon Dynasty release. This is one of the best kung fu movies ever made, I still remember watching it in theaters-it was a great experience.
Like a high-speed shootout in a flying car, I'm 'bout to get all over the place. Before I get going, I want to address the whole perfect-rating 5-star thing. As some of you may know, I have awarded the coveted 5-star rating to quite a few movies. I want to make something perfectly clear: I do not just pass that shit out haphazardly. I put a great deal of consideration into each of my reviews, and like many writers here I have seen thousands and thousands of movies, so after all that sampling it is not odd to come up with many pieces of brilliance and perfection. And that is what a 5-star rating entails to me: perfection. Perfection on many levels as well as a sense of accomlishing everything and more of what was intended by the filmmakers. A 5-star movie should entertain in ways that will instantly become memorable and capture many emotions. For me "A Man Called Hero" is such a movie.
This is my favorite Andrew Lau movie hands down. Maybe it's because I love comic books or something, but this film really appeals to me. It's very dark and moody with beautiful fantasy action. Loaded with interesting characters, wild special effects and a decent amount of martial arts. This is one of those grand fantasy movies where the line flying and special effects didn't bother me or detract from the movie, in fact they were necessary and enhanced the experience entirely. While I do dig "Storm Riders" and "The Duel", this will always be the one that stands out the most to me. Truly epic. This should have been a trilogy. Just about as cool as "Star Wars". I'm just sayin'.
STUFF THAT KICKS ASS: Ninjas with elemental super powers. Classic. Man with no arms who kicks like a hell raiser. Classic as well. Showdown on the statue of liberty that leaves the old girl looking like she got mugged by the jolly green giant. Wild, just wild.
MY CLOSING STATEMENTS BEFORE I GO GET SOMETHING TO EAT: This movie rocks and will appeal to fans of comics, fantasy and various old school classics.
I liked this movie but not enthusiastic as your review- The movie was a decent adaptation of the comic- but of course the comic is more detailed- but I enjoyed the flick it was fun.
Director Andrew Lau gets nailed a lot by some people, but I say he's the underappreciated pimp of 1990's HK cinema. He reinvented the triad genre with the Y&D flix, and took CGI fu well into the next level with the Storm Riders/Man Called Hero/Duel flix.
Golden Swallow [1968] (product link) Martial Arts / Action/Adventure
"Golden Swallow" is the follow-up to King Hu's classic film, "Come Drink With Me" with legendary director Chang Cheh at the helm and Cheng Pei Pei back for another round. Golden Swallow (Cheng Pei Pei) is living a peaceful life in a secluded valley with friend/protector Han Tao (Lo Lieh). Her world turns upside down when a mysterious swordman named Silver Roc (Jimmy Wang Yu) begins killing evil gangs in her name. Golden Swallow then begins to suspect that Silver Roc is a former classmate/love interest that disappeared years ago. Silver Roc reveals that he is conducting the massacres to lure out Golden Swallow in hopes of a reunion but conducts his business with no mercy, almost as if he is enjoying the slaughter. Golden Swallow goes off to clear her name and find the truth about Silver Roc's identity while Han Tao departs on his own mission to find out more information and protect her from harm. Silver Roc describes himself as an invincible swordsman with no home, although he often lives in a brothel with a sympathetic prostitute (Chao Hsin Yen). All of this builds up to a final climatic moment that is sure to alter everyone's living arrangements forever.
Very good preformances all around as Jimmy Wang Yu particularly shines coming off his 1967 classic, One Armed Swordsman. The action choreography of the great Lau Kar Leung is fast and furious as the viewer often needs to rewind and pause to see how Silver Roc cut down so many men with one stroke.
Director Chang Cheh also puts more emphasis on the characters' relationships and feelings (the love triangle) than many of his other films as it becomes the central plot instead of evil gang lords coming for revenge. Also notable is the beautiful scenery (mountains, waterfalls, sunsets) that is often seen throughout the film, which seems to go beyond the typical Shaw Bros. sets.
This is a great film that is a more than worthy addition to the King Hu/"Come Drink With Me" legacy.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
The film isn't quite as good as King Hu's "Come Drink With Me," but it is still extremely fine. If only Cheng Pei-pei had had a little more to do...
Hard Boiled (product link) Action/Adventure / Bullet Ballet This has to be one of the greatest, if not the greatest, action movies of all time. There is not a dull moment in the entire film. The last scene is absolutely incredible, and filled with so many touches that only Woo can provide; I love the classic diving and shooting at the same time move.
I would heartily recommend this, as well as Woo's "The Killer", to anyone. Even those that aren't fond of Hong Kong cinema will love this one.
I would put "A Better Tomorrow" (Part 1), "The Killer" and "Bullet in the Head" in a tie with this for John Woo's finest. If I had to choose, it would be a battle between this and "Bullet in the Head."
This is quite simply the greatest Gordon Liu movie ever made, and compelling arguments can be made that it is the greatest old-school kung fu film of all time.
While the story and plot may not be as deep or complicated as those found in movies by directors such as Chor Yuan, it serves as the perfect framework for some of the greatest fight scenes ever put on film. The array of weapons used is impressive, and the choreography is absolutely flawless; the hand-to-hand scenes are also quite incredible, including an amusing scene where our hero learns drunken kung fu.
As with most Shaw films of this period, particularly by this director, there is some comedy. But unlike most other old-school films that contain comedy, the jokes and gags in this movie are actually funny instead of just being annoying and tedious, and this manages to give the movie a light-hearted tone throughout most of its running-time.
This movie is a definite must-have in any old-school film collection. It is impossible to use too many superlatives when describing its greatness. Absolutely brilliant.
I like this film very much, but not only is it not the single greatest old-school kung fu film of all time, there are several other Gordon Liu films of similar quality.
Millionaires' Express (product link) Action/Adventure / Martial Arts What a big disappointment--I mean, literally everybody and their momma was in this movie. And this movie was like this!!!! WOW, you got to see it to believe it. Because this film, especially at this budget, should have been the best movie in history for all martial arts movie lovers. This movie, as slow as it was, could not make up for the lost time of the final scene. I am very, very unhappy right now.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
You are right on the spot MAN!!!! What a disappointment.
You gave Forbidden Kingdom 3 stars and this you only gave 2 and half. Are you serious? this movie is great, did you see the fight scenes. I don't think you saw the movie.
Whenever Millionaires' Express is brought up in a discussion among fu fans there is always 2 sides- people tht love it or hate it. I found the film fun & enjoyed the fights. The fights at the end are terrific. & the stars being silly is always nice.
I have to disagree. The last twenty or thirty minutes is one long, beautifully chaotic, explosive fight-fest. I found the filler between fights to be more compelling than most kung fu movies. I'll admit, some of the comedy antics are over-done.
Nope. You seem to be disregarding how well done and plentiful the action is toward the end. I also thought that there was enough humor and plot development throughout the film the keep things interesting.
I agree that the film was a let down, but I do think it had a lot of really cool fights and stunts in it. It was a bit bloated and meandering, but if you can look past that, I think you'll find the action to be quite enjoyable and noteworthy.
The One Armed Swordsman (product link) Martial Arts / Action/Adventure This is one of the best martial arts films ever made, equally as important to the genre as "A Better Tomorrow" was to heroic bloodshed in Hong Kong, paving the way for Bruce Lee and many others. Wang Yu was excellent in the starring role and has good chemistry with the adorable peasant girl (Chiao Chiao) that tried to free him from the martial arts world that never has a happy ending. Great film on every level, although some may view it as outdated.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
a very enjoyable film, despite Wang Yu's lack of martial arts talent.
totally with you there i think this film is a masterpiece and it's def one of jimmy wang yu's best films.i've just got the box set and love all 3 movies.
Sadly, this sequel is nowhere near as sharp as the original, with Ekin Cheng replacing Andy Lau and Lau Ching Wan returning to his previous role. I'm normally not a fan of Ekin Cheng, but he does a decent job here, although he is still no Andy Lau. There is more comedy in this one, mainly provided by a sad gambling-addicted character played by Johnnie To regular, Lam Suet.
This film tries to be stylish but often comes up empty. It really has no resemblence to the original except for some of the charcters, a charity donation, and Lau Ching Wan enjoying a bucket of chicken after failing to capture his suspect. The previous ultra catchy theme song was also brought back and given a French sounding remix. There were some good scenes, such as the bike ride on a rainy night, but I thought the ending was a complete letdown and never fully understood the use of the bald eagle.
This is still a decent film, as Johnnie To appears to be incapable of making a total stinker. It can be recommended but never compared with the original.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
I truly admire the first film, but this is a pointless, inferior rehash. Andy Lau's character engaged me, while Ekin Cheng's just made me restless.
Fighting Beat (product link) Martial Arts / Action/Adventure A low budget flick, but trust me, the action is mean. Another Tony Jaa wannabe, but he's really got skill. Tony Jaa's style jas become a trademark for Thai films!
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
N
This movie is pathetic, acting is crap, action is crap. Nice babes, but everything else crap, crap, crap.
Im still waiting to see a copy with good English subtitles to comment on the plot. The action is pretty good. Jija does the moves very well but her power is not believable. She needs to work on delivery of impact but other than that action is pretty good.
Heroes Two (product link) Action/Adventure / Martial Arts I was expecting not to like this one but it pleasantly suprised me. It's a decent Shaolin cycle movie. Basic Shaolin vs. Manchu plot. Good action by Fu Sheng and Chen Kuan Tai. Get if you are a fan of both.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
I was not surprised to like this. Cast and director are at their best in this genre. Chen Kuan Tai is quite formidable!
In this reveiwer's opinion, Leung Kar-Yan (aka Beardy) is one the most underrated actors and splendid fu artists who graced the HK screens in the late 70's and early 80's (although he still works in film, those were by far his best years). "Thundering Mantis" would be a mediocre fu flick at best without someone of Kar-Yan's magnetism. If you've seen (and likely enjoyed) Sammo Hung's "Knockabout", you know how well Kar-Yan can hold the screen comedically and with his high energy speedy hands in fights. "Thundering Mantis" captures the best of Kar-Yan's fighting talents while downplaying his true acting skills. The first hour of the movie sets the stage for the final half hour--namely, you see the happy-go-lucky but oft-bumbling Kar-Yan, fishseller and kung fu kid, as he pisses off a local thug. He then meets a young boy who is trying to steal fish from him, who then indirectly leads Kar-Yan to an older fu master who uses the mantis style. Some repetitive and predictable kung fu theatre filler goes on until the old man is killed and Kar-Yan seeks revenge. The last 15 minutes of the movie is worth the price of admission--some of the best fu, speed and control of handwork one can expect to see. Kar-Yan is a man possessed. If you aren't a Kar-Yan fan when you put this movie in, you will be when you're done with it!
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
Y
You're exactly right about Leung Kar-Yan's contributions to this film. It is unlikely the end sequence would have worked so well with any other star or persona in the lead. This works so very well.
I have never understood the fascination with the grossly overrated Wong Kar-Wai, and this movie does nothing to help me understand the kudos heaped upon this laughably pretentious director.
I don't care how beautiful a movie is if it fails to entertain, and this movie is so mind-numbingly boring any discussion of virtuoso cinematography and lavish set designs is pointless. This movie would put even the most ardent HK film-fan to sleep.
Anyone who has ever read reviews of this director's work will rarely, if ever, find words like fun, fast-paced, riveting, exciting or even entertaining. Instead we get descriptions that contain words like langurous, brooding, convoluted and my personal favorite from the lexicon of arrogant critic-speak, challenging. These are all just euphemisms for "boring", which is how all of Wong Kar-Wai's incomprehensible, supremely self-conscious, snore-inducing vanity pieces can be described.
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
N
The film wasn't meant to be a fast paced kung fu adventure. You're decrying a film for not being what the filmmaker didn't intend it to be.
I don't think you've seen this film. The imagery is better than any film to date. There's nothing wrong with beautiful visuals, and your just pissy because it's not your run of the mill Fu flick.
Chocolate [2008] (product link) Martial Arts / Action/Adventure "Chocolate" was an all right movie that features a new fighting talent, JeeJa Yanin. The film really should have focused on her talent more. The fights were great but nothing really amazing. The fights were basically her just dodging, punching and kicking guys, though the people she fought were really not that great or up to Jeeja Yanin standards--they could of filmed an awesome fight with somebody that knew how to fight.
Like I said before, the action is great but not amazing. So if you're an action fan then check this one out. But if you're a person that wants a good story with amazing action then pick up director Shunichi Nagasaki's "Kuro-Obi" aka "Black Belt".
AGREE?
READER COMMENTS
AUTHOR
N
YoMama says it best. This is high quality entertainment, but makes no pretense of artistry.
I am glad you criticize this movie, but if anything you rate it to high. I am continually amused by the responses of people who act like it is heresy to claim this mildly entertaining is anything less than the greatest thing since sliced bread.
The movie does deliver action. The action is not amazing as we seen it done before. The story is very sloppy and it did feel long. I agree with "Black Belt" is a great & smart martial arts movie.
got to disagree with your review lets face it how many martial arts films have good story's there aint many most people watch them for the action so in my opinion this film serves its purpose.
SECURE CREDIT CARD PROCESSING BY VERISIGN.
1010 users online right now / 496441 visitors since 11/29/2009 5:34:49 AM All content copyright 2000+ HKFlix.com, not to be used without written permission.